Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

Companies and equityBy US UK Tax Returns13 Nov 20267 min read

Relevant life policies and death-in-service cover for US citizen directors

Director at a desk beside a family photograph reviewing cover arranged through a relevant life policy US citizen setup

Cover bought by the company to protect a director's family is tax-free in the UK but is usually treated as extra pay on the director's US return.

A relevant life policy US citizen directors take out through their UK company is normally free of UK income tax on the premiums, but the US does not follow that result. The IRS excludes employer-paid life cover only within the group-term rules described in Publication 15-B (opens the official IRS page in a new tab), and an individual policy chosen for one director rarely fits them. The premiums can therefore be wages on your Form 1040 while the UK taxes nothing, which leaves no UK tax on that slice to credit.

This post is for US citizens and green card holders who run a UK limited company, or work as executives for one, and either have a relevant life policy or are covered by a group death-in-service scheme. It goes deeper on one benefit than our guide to US-UK tax for founders, fund managers and executives. It covers the UK charge, the company deduction, the section 79 question, the FBAR and Form 8938 position, Form 5471 and a decision list. Health cover is dealt with separately in our post on company-paid private medical insurance.

How is a relevant life policy taxed for a US citizen director in the UK

Usually lightly. HMRC's manual says the premiums an employer pays on a relevant life policy do not trigger a charge under the employer-financed retirement benefit rules, and a benefit-in-kind charge may be exempted by section 307 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003. Your nationality plays no part in that test.

A relevant life policy is a life policy, usually written in trust, that pays a lump sum if one named employee dies in service. HMRC's Employment Income Manual at EIM15045 lists the conditions: a capital sum payable on death before an age no later than 75, no surrender value, only permitted benefits, beneficiaries limited to individuals and charities, and no main purpose of avoiding tax. A group death-in-service policy meeting the same tests for many lives is an excepted group life policy.

Section 307 removes the benefits charge on an employer's cost of providing a lump sum or similar benefit payable on the employee's death. HMRC's guidance at EIM21800 adds that where a policy mixes qualifying and other cover, only the separable qualifying cost is exempt. If the scheme sits inside a registered pension scheme, the registered scheme rules in HMRC's Pensions Tax Manual apply instead, which is common for larger employers.

Can the company deduct relevant life premiums for corporation tax

Often, but not automatically. HMRC's Business Income Manual says pay and benefits for directors and employees are normally allowable as trading expenses, yet the company's purpose still has to be wholly and exclusively for its trade. For a sole director who also owns the shares, that purpose is the point HMRC is most likely to examine.

The manual at BIM37745 cites a case in which premiums on policies for two controlling directors were disallowed because the directors had in effect spent the money for their own benefit. The practical answer is to treat the policy as part of a reasonable remuneration package, recorded in board minutes or a service agreement, with cover in proportion to the director's pay and role.

Keep relevant life cover apart from key person cover. Key person insurance pays the company, not the family, and BIM45525 sets its own deduction conditions. Our business tax returns service prepares the corporation tax (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) computation with the premium classified correctly, and our payroll services team confirms whether anything needs reporting through PAYE and benefits (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) for the year.

Is a relevant life policy group-term life insurance under section 79

Generally no. Publication 15-B limits the group-term exclusion to cover given to a group of employees, in amounts set by a formula that prevents individual selection, and generally to at least ten full-time employees in the year. A policy bought for one director, at a sum that director picked, seldom meets those conditions.

Publication 15-B describes narrow exceptions for smaller employers, such as a plan available to all full-time employees on the basis of a medical questionnaire, but a relevant life policy is designed around one person. Where the section 79 rules do not apply, the general principle in Publication 525 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) takes over: a fringe benefit received for your services is income unless the law specifically excludes it.

The result is that the premium the company pays is likely to be compensation, valued at what the cover cost, and reportable as wages for the year it was paid. A UK company issues no Form W-2, so the figure comes from the company's records, converted to dollars and added to your salary on Form 1040. Our individual tax returns team asks for the policy schedule and premium history for that reason.

  • Cover for a single named director: usually outside section 79, premium likely wages
  • Company scheme for a formula-defined group of staff: section 79 may apply
  • Policy paying the company as beneficiary: key person cover, not the director's income
  • Any policy with a paid-up or cash surrender value: permanent benefit rules apply

How does the IRS treat a group death-in-service scheme

If it meets the group-term conditions, much more gently. Section 79 lets an employee exclude the cost of a set amount of group-term cover, fixed in the statute rather than in our figures here, and include only the cost of cover above it. That cost is not the premium; it comes from an age-banded IRS table.

Publication 15-B explains the method. Take the cover above the excludable amount, apply the monthly cost for your age band on the last day of the year from the table it prints, multiply by the months of cover and subtract anything you paid. Publication 525 has a worksheet for employees whose employer reports nothing, which is the usual position with a UK employer, and the result is added to wages.

Two cautions apply. Where a plan favours key employees, Publication 15-B includes the whole cost in their wages, and a scheme that covers only the directors of a small company is exposed to that. And where the cover sits inside a UK registered pension scheme, the US characterisation of that trust is a separate question to review with your preparer before you assume the group-term rules govern it.

Do term life policies go on the FBAR or Form 8938

Normally not, provided the policy has no cash value. FinCEN's FBAR instructions include an insurance policy with a cash value, such as whole life cover, in the definition of a financial account. A relevant life policy must have no surrender value to qualify in the UK, so it does not fit that description.

That conclusion rests on the policy terms, so read them. The FBAR (opens the official FinCEN page in a new tab) is filed with FinCEN, not the IRS, once your foreign accounts together exceed $10,000 at any point, and is due 15 April, extended automatically to 15 October. The Form 8938 rules (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) also reach cash value insurance held with a foreign insurer, so a pure protection policy with no surrender value is generally outside both. Our post on UK investment bonds and life policies on the FBAR covers policies that do build value.

One further point is worth raising with your adviser rather than assuming away. The Form 720 instructions place a federal excise tax on certain premiums paid to foreign insurers on the person who pays the premium and, failing that, on the person insured. A UK company paying a UK insurer to cover a US citizen's life is a case to review, including any treaty position.

What does the cover change on Form 5471

Mainly the expense line. If you control the company you are generally a category 4 filer of Form 5471, and the premiums sit within the company's expenses restated under US tax principles. Their treatment there should match how your own Form 1040 treats them.

The Instructions for Form 5471 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) require a category 4 filer to complete Schedule M, which reports transactions between the company and related parties during its accounting period, and Schedule H, which restates its earnings under US rules. A premium you report as wages is a compensation cost of the company; key person cover payable to the company is a different item. Late or incomplete filing carries an initial penalty of $10,000 per form per year, and our post on Form 5471 for a one-person UK limited company explains the schedules. The Form 5471 page lists what the company's accountant will be asked for.

Worked example: a US citizen founder in Edinburgh

A US citizen in Edinburgh owns all the shares in a UK design company, is its only director and has two part-time staff. On her accountant's advice the company starts a relevant life policy on her life, written in a discretionary trust for her children, with no surrender value. In the UK the premiums are a staff cost supported by a board minute, and no benefit is reported.

On her US return the policy is not group-term cover, because it is a single-life policy at a sum she chose. Her preparer adds each premium the company paid in the calendar year to her wages, converted at the year's average rate. She claims the foreign tax credit on Form 1116; no UK tax attaches to the premiums, but excess credits from her salary in the same category may absorb the extra US tax, and any surplus carries back one year and forward ten. She files by 15 June under the extension for taxpayers abroad.

The policy has no cash value, so it stays off her FBAR, and the premium appears as a compensation cost on Form 5471. Before renewing, she asks whether the trust suits a US person and whether the excise tax point applies. The founders guide sets out how the rest of her pay fits together.

  • UK policy tax-free under section 307 and US cover outside section 79: report the premium as US wages
  • Group scheme for a formula-defined staff group: use the IRS table cost above the excludable amount
  • Scheme favouring directors or key employees: expect the whole cost in US wages
  • Policy with any surrender value: check the FBAR, Form 8938 and permanent benefit rules
  • Salary sacrifice route: check for a UK charge as well as US wages
  • You control the company: match the premium's treatment on Form 5471 and your Form 1040

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

US-UK Tax for Founders, Fund Managers and Executives

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

My broker said a relevant life plan is tax-free. Is that wrong for an American?

It is right for UK income tax in most cases, because section 307 usually removes the benefits charge on employer-paid death cover. It is incomplete for a US citizen. The US exclusion applies to group-term cover meeting conditions an individual policy rarely meets, so the premiums are often wages on your US return. The UK answer and the US answer have to be checked separately.

Will the payout to my family be taxed in the US?

That depends on who owns the policy, how the trust is drafted and where your beneficiaries live, and it sits outside the scope of this post. A standard UK policy trust was not written with US estate and trust rules in mind, so ask for a review of the trust deed before the policy starts, not after a claim.

Can I just pay the premiums myself to avoid US wages?

You could own a personal term policy instead, and then there is no employer benefit to report in either country. The trade-off is that you pay from income that has already been taxed and the company loses the deduction. Whether that is better depends on your marginal rates in both countries and your foreign tax credit position, so model it before switching.

Does my green card status change any of this?

Generally not. A green card holder is usually taxed by the US on worldwide income like a citizen, so the same section 79 analysis applies to employer-paid cover. The UK treatment depends on your employment with the company, not your immigration status. If you claim treaty residence in the UK to be taxed as a nonresident, the US position changes, and that needs advice first.

I never reported past premiums on my US returns. What should I do?

Gather the premium history and policy schedule, then work out whether the policy was group-term cover or an individual one. If the premiums were wages, amended returns on Form 1040-X can add them, with any foreign tax credit adjustment. Where several years and other gaps are involved, the streamlined procedures may be relevant, and the right route depends on your conduct and facts.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us