Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

Companies and equityBy US UK Tax Returns19 Nov 20268 min read

SEIS and EIS investments for US citizens

Investor reads papers on a sofa as founders sketch plans on a whiteboard, an SEIS EIS US citizen investment

UK relief for backing an early-stage company does not travel to the US return, which taxes the same investment on its own terms.

SEIS and EIS relief reduces your UK tax and nothing else. The United States has no matching relief, so a US citizen who subscribes under either scheme often ends up with less UK tax to set against US tax, and a gain HMRC exempts after the holding period is still a capital gain on Form 1040. How much of the UK benefit survives depends on how much spare foreign tax credit you already have.

This post is for US citizens and green card holders in the UK who back early-stage companies as angels, and for founders asking whether outside SEIS or EIS money changes anything for them personally. It goes deeper on one question than our guide to US-UK tax for founders, fund managers and executives: what each stage of an investment looks like on the US side, from the subscription year to an exit, a failure or a clawback, and which US forms a holding can bring with it.

What do SEIS and EIS give a UK investor

Both schemes reward subscribing for new shares in small unquoted trading companies. HMRC's venture capital schemes guidance (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) lists an income tax reduction for the investment, a capital gains exemption on a sale after the minimum holding period, and relief for a loss against income. Rates and annual limits differ between the two schemes.

The holding period is at least three years, and the company's compliance certificate, form SEIS3 or EIS3, tells you how long it runs for your shares. You claim using that certificate and may carry some or all of the investment back a year. Unused income tax relief cannot be carried forward, so the relief is only as large as the UK income tax available to reduce.

EIS also lets you defer tax on a gain from any asset by reinvesting in EIS shares, and SEIS reinvestment relief takes part of a gain out of charge. Income tax relief is closed to connected investors: employees, holders of more than a set share of the capital or votes and, for EIS, most paid directors. EIS deferral can still apply to a connected investor, which is why founders ask about it.

Does SEIS or EIS relief cost a US citizen foreign tax credit

Often it does. Publication 514 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) allows a credit only for your legal and actual foreign tax liability, and says foreign tax reduced or offset by a credit does not qualify. SEIS or EIS relief lowers your UK income tax bill, so the UK tax available to credit against US tax on that income falls by the same amount.

Whether that costs you anything turns on the gap between the two countries' tax on the same income. A US citizen employed in the UK usually pays more UK tax on salary than the US would charge, and the excess becomes unused credit that carries back one year and forward ten years. If the relief only eats into that excess, US tax on the salary stays at nil and the whole UK benefit is yours. If it pushes UK tax below the US tax on the same income, the foreign tax credit (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) stops covering it and the shortfall is payable to the IRS.

Put plainly, the relief can move money from HMRC to the IRS without any of it staying with you. An angel should rule that out before committing, using the Form 1116 figures from the last return. Our tax planning work runs both returns side by side for the year of subscription and any year you carry relief back to.

Is an SEIS or EIS gain taxable in the US

Yes. The UK exemption for shares held through the holding period has no US counterpart. A US citizen reports the sale as a capital gain under the rules in Publication 550 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab), long-term if the shares were held for more than one year, and there is no UK tax on that gain to credit against the US tax.

The US gain is measured in dollars. Cost is converted at the rate on the day you subscribed and proceeds at the rate on the day of sale, so a swing in sterling can change the US gain even where the pound figure barely moved. HMRC works in sterling, as its guidance on tax when you sell shares (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) explains. Our post on selling a UK company as a US citizen covers earn-outs and deferred consideration.

A gain can also bring the net investment income tax at 3.8% once income passes the US thresholds. That tax is generally not creditable under domestic law, and treaty-based claims are contested, so an exempt UK gain may carry a US charge with nothing to offset it. EIS deferral gives no US deferral: the original sale is taxed in the US in its own year.

How does the US treat a failed SEIS or EIS company

As a capital loss. UK loss relief lets you set a loss on SEIS or EIS shares, after deducting the income tax relief already given, against your income. The US gives you a capital loss instead, which offsets capital gains first and only a limited amount of other income each year, with the balance carried forward.

The two losses are measured differently. The UK figure is reduced by the income tax relief you received, while the US loss starts from your dollar cost. An angel can have a UK loss that cuts tax on salary at once and a US loss that takes years to use unless other gains absorb it.

The UK claim also feeds back into the credit. Setting the loss against salary lowers UK income tax for that year and so the credit available on the salary, exactly as the original relief did. Where the margin between UK and US tax is thin, the claim can create US tax on wages while the US capital loss is released slowly.

Which US forms can SEIS or EIS shares trigger

Shares held directly in a UK company are a specified foreign financial asset, so they count towards Form 8938 once your foreign assets pass the reporting threshold. A larger stake can bring Form 5471, and a company with enough passive income or assets can bring PFIC reporting.

The IRS questions and answers on Form 8938 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) confirm that foreign stock held outside a financial account is reportable. For a US citizen living abroad the threshold is $200,000 at year end or $300,000 at any time when not filing jointly, or $400,000 at year end or $600,000 at any time on a joint return. The Instructions for Form 8938 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) allow a reasonable estimate of value, and shares reported on a timely Form 5471 or Form 8621 are not listed again.

SEIS and EIS exclude investors above a set share of the company, but that ceiling sits well above the US line. Under the Instructions for Form 5471 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab), a US person whose acquisition takes them to a tenth or more of the vote or value files as a Category 3 filer for that year. If US shareholders of that size together own more than half, the company is a controlled foreign corporation and each of them files every year.

The PFIC question turns on the company, not the scheme. The Instructions for Form 8621 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) set out an income test and an asset test. A young company holding mostly cash from its latest round, with little revenue, is worth checking each year. Where an EIS fund holds shares in each company for you, test each company; a pooled vehicle that is itself a company raises the question at fund level, as our post on whether UK investment trusts are PFICs explains. Our PFIC reporting team handles the elections.

  • Form 8938: direct shareholdings once foreign assets pass the threshold
  • Form 5471: an acquisition reaching a tenth of the vote or value
  • Form 8621: only if the company or fund meets a PFIC test
  • Form 1116: each year relief or a loss claim changes your UK tax
  • Schedule D and Form 8949: every sale, including a UK-exempt one

What happens in the US if HMRC claws back the relief

HMRC withdraws relief if, within the holding period, you dispose of the shares, become connected with the company, receive money or assets from it, or the company stops qualifying. HMRC's manual says EIS relief is withdrawn for the tax year in which it was obtained, so the extra UK tax belongs to an earlier year.

Withdrawal does not run through your own return. HMRC recovers the relief by a separate assessment, and its investor guidance requires you to report a withdrawal event within a short time limit. On the US side, Publication 514 says a change in foreign tax that alters your US tax generally means an amended return with a revised Form 1116, and it allows ten years to claim a refund arising from a change in the credit. When the extra UK tax counts as paid can depend on whether you claim credits on the cash or accrual basis, so settle the year to amend before filing.

How does this play out for a US citizen angel investor

A US citizen working as an engineer in Bristol subscribes for EIS shares in a software company run by a former colleague. She is neither an employee nor a director and holds a small minority stake, so she claims UK income tax relief using the EIS3 certificate.

Her UK tax on salary is well above the US tax on the same pay, and our individual tax returns work shows unused credits carried forward. The relief uses part of that surplus, so her US tax on salary stays at nil. Each year her preparer checks the accounts against the PFIC tests, lists the shares on Form 8938 when required and confirms her stake stays below a tenth.

Four years on, the company is sold. The UK gain is exempt; her US return shows a long-term capital gain in dollars with no UK tax to credit, and her preparer tests the net investment income tax. She files by 15 June under the extension for taxpayers abroad. Our guide to US-UK tax for founders, fund managers and executives covers the company-side filings, and our post on EMI options and US citizens deals with equity received as an employee rather than bought as an investor.

  • Large surplus of UK tax over US tax on salary: relief usually kept in full
  • Thin margin between UK and US tax: model the US cost before subscribing
  • Little UK income tax to reduce: relief is lost, as it cannot be carried forward
  • Exit after the holding period: UK gain exempt, full US capital gain, possible NIIT
  • Company fails: UK loss against income, US capital loss at the annual limit
  • Stake reaching a tenth of the vote or value: Form 5471 joins the return

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

US-UK Tax for Founders, Fund Managers and Executives

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

Can I claim SEIS relief on my US tax return?

No. SEIS and EIS are UK reliefs, and US tax law has no matching deduction or credit for subscribing to shares in a UK company. For US purposes the investment is simply a purchase of stock, giving you a dollar cost. The only US effect of the UK relief is indirect: it lowers the UK tax you can credit, which may or may not raise your US bill.

Should a US citizen living in the UK avoid EIS altogether?

Not necessarily. Where your UK tax on salary or other income already exceeds the US tax on it, the relief often uses surplus credit and costs nothing in the US. It is harder to justify where your UK and US tax are close, where a tax-free UK exit is the main attraction, or where the company may be a PFIC. Model both returns before you subscribe.

Does the three-year EIS rule line up with the US one-year rule for long-term gains?

They measure different things. The UK holding period protects the reliefs and is generally at least three years, as the company's certificate confirms. The US treats a gain as long-term once the shares were held for more than one year. A sale between those points is long-term in the US, while in the UK the relief is withdrawn and the gain is chargeable, which at least gives you UK tax to credit.

I founded the company. Can I get EIS relief on my own shares?

Usually not. Income tax relief is closed to investors connected with the company, which includes employees, people holding more than a set share of its capital or votes and, for EIS, most paid directors. EIS deferral relief can still apply to a connected investor reinvesting a gain, but the US taxes that gain in the year of the original sale whatever the UK defers.

What paperwork should I keep for SEIS and EIS shares?

Keep the SEIS3 or EIS3 certificate, the subscription date and the exchange rate for that day, the claim workings for each UK return and the company's annual accounts. The accounts support the PFIC tests and the Form 8938 valuation, the certificate fixes the UK holding period, and the dollar cost is the figure the US gain or loss will be measured from years later.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us