Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

Companies and equityBy US UK Tax Returns17 Nov 20268 min read

Interest-free loan from employer: the US tax for American executives in the UK

Two colleagues review a printed loan agreement in a London office, an interest-free loan from employer

A cheap loan from a UK employer is a benefit for HMRC and can still fall within the US below-market loan rules for an American.

An interest-free loan from employer funds, such as a season ticket loan, is a beneficial loan for HMRC, taxed on a notional interest figure unless the balance stays under a small-loan ceiling for the whole tax year. A US citizen has a second set of rules. Section 7872 treats a cheap loan from an employer as a compensation-related loan, and the regulation that exempts many loans from foreign lenders expressly leaves this kind out. Publication 550 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) explains how the forgone interest is treated as pay.

This post is for US citizens and green card holders employed in the UK who have borrowed from their employer at no interest or below a market rate: season tickets, rent deposits, loans to buy shares or a bridging advance. It goes further on one benefit than our guide to US-UK tax for founders, fund managers and executives. Owner-directors who borrow from their own company face a separate US problem, covered in our post on section 956 and director's loans. Here we cover the UK charge, why the US rules still apply, the small-loan exceptions, write-offs and a worked example.

How does HMRC tax an interest-free loan from employer funds

As a benefit in kind. If you pay less interest than HMRC's official rate, the difference is treated as part of your employment income and your employer reports it on form P11D. The charge falls away where the combined balance of all such loans stays below HMRC's small-loan ceiling throughout the tax year.

GOV.UK's guidance on loans provided to employees (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) sets out the rules for employers. A beneficial loan is one that is interest-free or charged at less than the official rate, and the rules reach loans the employer arranges, guarantees or takes over from someone else, not only those it lends itself. The employer pays Class 1A National Insurance on the value of the benefit. Your share of the charge comes through your tax code or your Self Assessment return, depending on how the rest of your affairs are handled.

The exemptions matter more than the charge for most season ticket borrowers. The small-loan test looks at the total outstanding across all your beneficial loans from that employment, and it must be met for the whole tax year, not just at 5 April. A loan that starts above the ceiling and is paid down below it does not qualify for that year. Our payroll services team checks the P11D entries against the loan schedule, because a missed second loan can break the exemption.

  • Combined balance below the small-loan ceiling for the entire tax year
  • Fixed-term, fixed-rate loans at or above the official rate when taken out
  • Loans offered on the same terms to members of the public
  • Loans where all the interest would qualify for tax relief
  • A director's loan account that is never overdrawn in the tax year

Does section 7872 apply when the lender is a UK company

Yes, for an employee. Section 7872 covers compensation-related loans, meaning below-market loans between an employer and an employee, and nothing in the statute limits it to US employers. The temporary regulations exempt certain loans from a foreign lender to a US borrower, but that exemption excludes compensation-related loans in its own wording.

Treasury Regulation 1.7872-5T lists loans treated as having no significant effect on federal tax. One entry covers below-market loans where the lender is a foreign person and the borrower is a US person, provided the interest imputed to the lender would not be taxed in the US. The text then carves out compensation-related loans, and corporation-shareholder loans to a shareholder who is not a C corporation. A London employer lending to an American member of staff therefore stays inside the rules, as does a UK company lending to its American shareholder.

The same regulation has a general exemption for loans whose interest arrangements make no significant difference to anyone's tax, judged on all the facts. It weighs the size of the items, the cost of compliance and the non-tax reasons for lending interest-free. A small season ticket loan may well fit it, but the regulation also says that structuring a loan to fit any exemption, where avoiding tax is a principal purpose, turns it into a tax avoidance loan. We record the reasoning on file rather than assume it.

When does the US small-loan exception keep you out

On any day when the total of all loans outstanding between you and your employer is at or below a de minimis ceiling written into section 7872, provided avoiding federal tax is not a principal purpose. Publication 550 says this exception applies to compensation-related loans but not to term loans.

The UK and US ceilings happen to be the same number, one in pounds and one in dollars. That is a trap. While sterling is worth more than the dollar, a season ticket loan sitting comfortably under the HMRC ceiling can be over the US one once converted at the day's rate, using the Treasury reporting rates (opens the official US Treasury page in a new tab) or another consistent source. The US test also works day by day, where the UK test looks at the whole tax year, so a loan can be in the US rules for some months and out of them for the rest.

Whether the loan is a demand loan or a term loan turns on its paperwork. A loan repayable in full whenever the employer asks is a demand loan. A season ticket loan repaid by fixed monthly payroll deductions over a year, with no right to call it in early except on leaving, can look more like a term loan, which Publication 550 places outside the small-loan exception. Ask your employer for the loan agreement, not just the payslip deductions, before you decide.

How the forgone interest reaches your Form 1040

As extra pay. For a demand loan, the forgone interest is the interest at the applicable federal rate, less any interest you actually pay, treated as paid to you on 31 December each year. You are then treated as paying the same amount back to your employer as interest, which is personal and usually not deductible.

Publication 550 explains that the borrower may deduct the deemed interest only where the loan proceeds are used for business or investment. A season ticket or a rent deposit is neither. So the net effect is a small addition to wages on Form 1040 with nothing to set against it. For a below-market term loan, the treatment is front-loaded: the employer is treated as paying you, on the day the loan is made, the difference between the amount lent and the present value of the repayments, with the same figure then treated as original issue discount over the term.

The applicable federal rates are published monthly by the IRS in dollar terms. There is no separate published rate for a sterling loan, so the rate used for a pound-denominated loan is a judgment we document. The imputed pay is compensation for work done in the UK, so it sits in the general category on Form 1116. Where HMRC charges tax on the same benefit, that UK tax is creditable under the Form 1116 instructions (opens the official IRS page in a new tab). Where the UK exemption applies, there is no UK tax on it, but spare credits from your salary often absorb the US tax.

  • Find the loan agreement and decide whether it is a demand or term loan
  • Convert the balance each day it matters, or at a consistent monthly rate
  • Apply the applicable federal rate for the month or term concerned
  • Add the forgone interest to compensation and test the foreign tax credit

What happens if your employer writes the loan off

Both countries tax it. GOV.UK says an employer must always report a loan it writes off and must deduct Class 1 National Insurance on it through payroll, though not PAYE tax. The amount written off is then taxed as employment income. In the US, a cancelled debt is generally income, and from an employer it is normally pay.

Write-offs often happen on leaving. A season ticket loan forgiven as a goodwill gesture, or an advance an employer decides not to collect, falls within these rules, and the date of the write-off decides which UK tax year and which US calendar year it lands in. The UK income tax on the amount is collected through your tax code or your Self Assessment return, so check the P11D figure before you file the SA100, due online by 31 January. Keep the employer's letter confirming the date and the amount forgiven.

Publication 525 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) says a cancelled debt is income unless it is a genuine gift, and that where a corporation cancels a shareholder's debt, it is a constructive distribution that is generally a dividend. For an employee with no shares, the write-off is compensation and goes on Form 1040 with the UK tax credited against it. For an owner-director the dividend reading may apply instead, and loans between a controlled company and its US shareholder appear on Schedule M of Form 5471. The Instructions for Form 5471 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) cover that schedule.

A worked example: a season ticket loan in London

A US citizen operations director at a London insurer, holding no shares, takes an annual rail season ticket loan repaid through twelve monthly payroll deductions. The balance is below HMRC's ceiling all year, so there is no UK benefit charge and nothing on the P11D. The loan agreement lets the employer call it in only if she leaves.

On her US return the picture is different. Converted to dollars, the balance is above the US ceiling for the first months of the year, and the fixed repayment schedule makes the loan look like a term loan, which falls outside the US small-loan exception anyway. We treat it as a below-market term loan, impute the difference between the amount lent and the present value of the repayments as compensation in the month the loan was made, and spread the matching original issue discount over the year.

The amount is small and her UK salary carries general category credits well beyond it, so no extra US tax is due. The point is that it was worked out and disclosed, rather than missed. Our individual tax returns and cross-border tax teams run this check for any employee loan, and the founders and executives guide sets out how loans fit with the rest of an executive's pay. Before signing an employer loan, check:

  • Is the balance below the HMRC ceiling for every day of the tax year
  • Is the dollar equivalent below the US ceiling, and on which days
  • Is the agreement a demand loan or a term loan
  • Who pays the tax if the employer later writes the loan off
  • Are you also a shareholder, bringing in the corporation-shareholder rules

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

US-UK Tax for Founders, Fund Managers and Executives

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

My season ticket loan is tax-free in the UK. Do I need to mention it to the IRS at all?

Possibly. The UK small-loan exemption does not carry over. If the dollar value of everything you owe your employer goes above the US de minimis ceiling, or the loan counts as a term loan, section 7872 can impute interest as pay. The amount is usually small and often covered by foreign tax credits, but it should be worked out and kept on file.

Does it matter that my employer is British and has no US presence?

Not for this rule. The regulation that exempts some loans from foreign lenders to US borrowers specifically excludes compensation-related loans. Your employer has no US filing to make, so the calculation falls to you on your own return. It also means no Form W-2 or 1099 will prompt you, which is why these loans are easy to miss.

Can I deduct the imputed interest I am treated as paying back?

Usually not. Section 7872 treats you as receiving extra pay and then paying the same sum back as interest. Publication 550 says the borrower may deduct it only where the loan was used for business or investment. Money spent on a rail ticket or a rent deposit is personal, so the deemed interest gives no deduction and the extra pay stands on its own.

My employer lent me money to buy shares in the company. Is that treated the same way?

The same US rules apply to the loan, and section 7872 looks at all loans between you and the employer together. In the UK, a loan where all the interest would qualify for tax relief is exempt from the beneficial loan charge, and some share purchase loans can qualify. The shares themselves raise separate questions about reporting and passive foreign investment company status, so we look at them alongside the loan.

Which exchange rate should I use to compare my loan with the US ceiling?

The IRS does not prescribe one rate for this purpose. Because the US test works day by day, a daily rate is the most precise. Many people use a consistent published source, such as the Treasury reporting rates, applied monthly. Whatever you choose, use it for the whole year and keep a note of it, because the same choice should hold if the IRS asks.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us