Private medical insurance paid by a UK employer is taxed in the UK and usually not in the US. HMRC treats the premium as a benefit in kind, taxed on the employee through their tax code or payroll, with Class 1A National Insurance on the employer. US law generally excludes employer-provided health cover from income, which IRS Publication 525 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) confirms for most cases. The practical risk is copying UK pay figures straight onto Form 1040.
This post is for US citizens and green card holders who are directors of their own UK company, and for executives employed by a UK business, who have company-paid health cover. It goes deeper on one benefit than our guide to US-UK tax for founders, fund managers and executives does. It covers the UK charge, the US exclusion, how to read a P60 or P11D for a US return, the effect on the foreign tax credit, and how the premium appears in the company's Form 5471.
How is company-paid private medical insurance taxed in the UK
In the UK, medical insurance that an employer arranges and pays for is a taxable benefit in kind. The employee pays income tax on the cost to the employer, and the employer pays Class 1A National Insurance on the same value. The employee pays no National Insurance on it when the employer contracts with the insurer directly.
GOV.UK's employer guidance on medical and dental treatment and insurance says the value to use is the cost to the employer of providing the cover. Where the employer contracts directly with the insurer, the benefit goes on form P11D and Class 1A is due. Where the employee arranges the cover and the employer settles the bill, the amount is also added to earnings for Class 1 National Insurance. A cash allowance or reimbursement is treated as pay and runs through PAYE (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) in full.
HMRC usually collects the employee's tax through their tax code, spreading it over the year. HMRC lists a short set of exemptions: one health screening or medical check a year, treatment abroad for an employee working overseas for the employer, cover limited to work-related injury or illness, and return-to-work treatment up to a capped amount. Ordinary private medical insurance is not on the list, and salary sacrifice does not change that.
- Employer contracts and pays the insurer: P11D or payrolled, Class 1A on the employer
- Employee contracts, employer pays the insurer: P11D plus Class 1 National Insurance through payroll
- Employer reimburses the employee or pays an allowance: treated as earnings through PAYE
- Cover under salary sacrifice: still reportable, using the higher of the cost or the salary given up
What changes when medical benefits are payrolled from April 2027
From 6 April 2027, HMRC's guidance says employers must report medical insurance through payroll software rather than on a P11D. The taxable value is added to the employee's pay each payday, and tax is deducted there. Many employers already do this voluntarily, which affects the figures a US filer reads from their UK paperwork.
HMRC's guidance on voluntary payrolling says the taxable amount of the benefit is added to the employee's pay, and that it must be included in the total taxable pay for the year on the P60. Medical insurance sits in the first group of benefits that HMRC's draft guidance makes mandatory from April 2027, alongside company cars, vans and fuel. For a US citizen this means the P60 pay figure is no longer the same as US wages. A P11D listed the benefit separately. Once payrolled, the premium sits inside the P60 total, and a return that copies that figure reports income the US does not tax.
Does the US tax employer-paid private medical insurance
Generally, no. Under section 106 of the Internal Revenue Code, employer contributions to an accident or health plan for employees are excluded from income. IRS Publication 525 says the value of accident or health cover provided by an employer is in most cases not included in income, and the publication does not limit the rule to US employers or US insurers.
The exclusion depends on the person being an employee and the cover being an accident or health plan. IRS Publication 15 says corporate officers who work in the business are employees of the corporation, which is the usual position for a director who works in their own UK company. The IRS treats a more than two per cent shareholder of an S corporation as a partner for this purpose, but a UK limited company cannot be an S corporation, so that rule does not normally reach a UK company.
Three situations need a closer look. A cash allowance, or a reimbursement paid as salary, is wages in both countries. Cover bought under salary sacrifice raises the question of whether the employee chose cash or cover, which depends on how the arrangement is documented. And the exclusion covers the premium, while benefits received from the plan follow their own rules in Publication 525.
How the UK and US treatment of private medical insurance compare
The two systems reach opposite answers on the same premium. The UK taxes it as earnings of the employee and charges the employer National Insurance on it, while the US generally treats it as excluded cover. The comparison below sets out the differences for a US citizen employee in the UK.
The differences matter most in three places: the wage figure on the US return, the foreign tax credit calculation on Form 1116, and the company's own accounts where the employee also owns the business. None creates extra US tax by itself, but each can leave a US return that does not reconcile to the UK figures.
- Employee income: UK taxable benefit in kind; US generally excluded under section 106
- Employer social security: UK Class 1A National Insurance; US Social Security and Medicare not relevant to a UK employer
- Reporting: UK P11D, or payroll and P60 from April 2027; US no separate form for the excluded cover
- Tax year: UK 6 April to 5 April; US calendar year, so premiums are split across two UK years
- Value: UK cost to the employer; US value of the cover, not normally reported where excluded
- Company figures: a staff cost in the UK accounts; generally a reduction in US earnings and profits
Does UK tax on the benefit still count for the foreign tax credit
The UK tax on the benefit is income tax on employment income, and it is part of the UK tax paid for the year. The difficulty is that the US does not count the premium as income, so part of the UK tax relates to an amount missing from the US calculation. How that tax is allocated depends on the facts.
The Treasury regulations on allocating foreign tax give special treatment to tax on a short, closed list of receipts the US does not count as income, known as base differences. Employer health cover is not on that list, so the UK tax on it is allocated under the general rules on the Form 1116 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) calculation. The Instructions for Form 1116 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) separate wages, which are general category income, from passive income such as dividends.
In practice the effect is often small. A US citizen paying UK tax on a salary of any size usually has more UK tax in the general category than the US tax on the same wages, so the credit is capped and the surplus carries back one year and forward ten. Where a filer uses the foreign earned income exclusion (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) instead, the Form 1116 instructions require taxes allocable to the excluded wages to be removed, and the UK tax on the benefit needs the same scrutiny. Our post comparing the foreign tax credit and the exclusion in the UK covers that choice.
Where the premium appears on Form 5471 for a founder's company
For a US founder who controls a UK company, the premium is a company expense before it is anything else. It reduces the profit shown in the company's accounts, and it is generally reflected the same way in the income statement and earnings and profits figures reported on Form 5471. There is no separate line for the benefit.
The Instructions for Form 5471 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) set out how the company's figures are translated into US dollars, and earnings and profits are measured under US tax principles rather than UK accounting rules. Ordinary compensation costs, including health cover for employees, are generally deductible under those principles, so the premium usually lowers current earnings and the income tested under the controlled foreign corporation rules. A missing or incomplete form carries an initial penalty of $10,000, so the figures should be built from the same ledger as the corporation tax (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) return.
Where the cover is for the founder alone, it should be set up as an employee benefit through a board decision and an employer policy. A company that simply pays a personal policy risks the payment looking like a distribution or a shareholder loan, which changes both returns. Our post on Form 5471 for a one-person UK limited company covers the filing.
Worked example and checklist for a US director with company cover
The steps are the same for an owner and an executive: identify how the cover is provided, find its value in the UK paperwork, remove it from US wages, and keep the UK tax in the credit calculation. The example shows a founder whose company starts payrolling the benefit.
Take a US citizen living in Bristol who is the sole director and shareholder of a UK consultancy, paid a salary through PAYE, with a company policy covering her alone. Until the company payrolled benefits, her P11D showed the premium and her P60 showed salary only. Once payrolled, the P60 taxable pay included the premium, so her preparer took the P60 figure, removed the payrolled benefit and converted the balance for Form 1040. Her UK tax for the year went into the Form 1116 workings, where the general category credit was already capped by her salary, so the allocation question did not change the result and the surplus carried forward.
On the company side, the premium was booked as staff cost, so it lowered the profit on her Form 5471 and on the corporation tax return in the same way. Our individual tax returns and business tax returns services handle both sides together, and payroll services can set up the employer reporting. The guide to US-UK tax for founders, fund managers and executives covers the wider salary and dividend decision.
- Find the policy schedule and confirm who contracts with the insurer
- Check whether the employer reports the cover on a P11D or through payroll
- Remove any payrolled premium from the P60 figure before reporting US wages
- Treat cash allowances and reimbursements as wages in both countries
- Keep the full UK tax paid in the Form 1116 workings and review its allocation
- For an owned company, record a board decision and book the premium as staff cost
General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.



