Personal injury compensation from a UK claim is, for US tax, mostly outside income: section 104(a)(2) excludes damages received on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness, whether paid as a lump sum or in instalments. The two systems part company on interest. The UK exempts interest built into a personal injury award, while Publication 525 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) treats interest on any award as ordinary income. Punitive damages, earlier-deducted medical costs and claims without a physical injury are also taxable in the US.
This post is for US citizens and green card holders living in Britain who have received, or expect, damages after a road accident, an injury at work or clinical negligence, or an award under the Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme. It goes further than our guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation on one payment. It sets out each country's rules, breaks a typical award into its heads of loss, follows the credit consequences when only one side taxes, and ends with an example by role.
Is UK personal injury compensation taxable on a US return
Mostly not. Section 104(a)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code excludes the amount of any damages, other than punitive damages, received by suit or agreement on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness. The exclusion does not depend on which country's court or insurer pays, so a UK settlement qualifies on the same terms.
The statute carries its own carve-outs. The opening words of section 104(a) take back amounts attributable to medical expenses deducted under section 213 in an earlier year. Emotional distress is not itself a physical injury, although distress flowing from one is treated as part of it. Publication 525 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) then lists items that stay taxable even in an injury case: interest on any award, and punitive damages whether or not they relate to a physical injury.
The IRS settlement leaflet, Publication 4345, puts the core rule plainly. A settlement for physical injury or sickness is non-taxable in full where no medical deduction was taken for it in earlier years. Where one was taken and gave a tax benefit, that slice is reported as other income on Schedule 1. The rest of the award, which is usually most of it, never reaches the Form 1040 as income at all.
How does the UK tax personal injury damages and interest
Lightly. Section 51(2) of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 declares that compensation for a wrong or injury suffered by an individual in their person is not a chargeable gain. Section 751 of the Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005 exempts interest on personal injury damages, including interest inside an out-of-court settlement.
HMRC's Capital Gains Manual reads the words in his person widely. They cover physical injury, and also distress, embarrassment, loss of reputation or dignity, discrimination and defamation. The interest exemption has limits that HMRC's Savings and Investment Manual spells out. It does not reach interest for the period between judgment and payment, and it does not reach interest or gains once the award has been invested. Interest on a foreign court's award is exempt only if it is also exempt where the award was made.
Periodical payments have their own code. Section 731 exempts payments under a court order made under section 2 of the Damages Act 1996, under a settlement of a personal injury claim, or under a Motor Insurers' Bureau undertaking. Section 732 exempts annuity payments bought under a Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme award. Section 734 extends the relief to sums paid from a trust where the injured person is the only possible lifetime beneficiary. Where a taxable slice remains, it belongs on a Self Assessment return (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab).
Where do the US and UK rules diverge
At four points: interest before judgment, claims with no physical injury, Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme awards, and payments from your own employer. Elsewhere the two systems usually agree that damages for a physical injury are not income, and that the return on money you later invest is taxable in both.
The first is the common one. A UK award or settlement normally includes interest running from the date of the accident or the claim. The UK exempts it under section 751. The US does not, because Publication 4345 treats interest on any settlement as interest income. The second follows from the word physical. The UK exemption covers distress and reputation; section 104 does not, apart from damages up to the cost of medical care for the distress.
- Interest up to judgment or settlement. UK exempt; US taxable as interest income
- Interest after judgment, and returns on investing the award. Taxable in both countries
- Damages for distress, discrimination or defamation with no physical injury. Outside UK capital gains tax; taxable in the US beyond medical costs for the distress
- Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme awards. UK annuities exempt by statute; the US position needs its own analysis, because Treasury regulations define damages by reference to a suit or a settlement of one
- Injury payments from your own employer. HMRC's employment rules apply, and payments calculated for time off work are usually taxed as earnings
Personal injury compensation US tax UK: a component-by-component list
Take the settlement breakdown or the judgment and test each head of loss separately. The US treats the whole of a physical injury award as excluded except interest, punitive amounts and medical costs you previously deducted. The UK exempts almost everything, including pre-judgment interest, but taxes post-judgment interest and later investment income.
UK solicitors describe awards in heads of loss, which helps. General damages compensate for pain, suffering and loss of amenity. Special damages cover past financial losses such as earnings and care. Future loss covers what the injury will cost from here on. Publication 4345 treats lost wages as taxable only in employment-related lawsuits, such as unfair dismissal or discrimination, so lost earnings inside a physical injury award fall within the exclusion with everything else.
- General damages for pain, suffering and loss of amenity. US: excluded. UK: not taxable
- Past and future loss of earnings in an injury claim. US: excluded as damages on account of the injury. UK: part of the damages
- Care, treatment and equipment costs. US: excluded, unless you deducted the medical costs in an earlier year and got a tax benefit. UK: part of the damages
- Interest to judgment or settlement. US: taxable, foreign source and passive category. UK: exempt
- Interest after judgment and investment returns. US: taxable. UK: taxable
- Exemplary or other punitive damages. US: taxable as other income. UK: check the facts
What happens to the foreign tax credit when only one country taxes
Usually there is nothing to credit. Where the US taxes interest that the UK exempts, no UK tax was paid on it, so the foreign tax credit (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) cannot cover it from this item. Where both countries tax post-judgment interest, the UK tax you finally owe can be credited within the passive category limit.
Interest is sourced by the residence of the payer, as the source table in Publication 519 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) shows, so interest paid by a UK insurer or other UK payer is foreign source. On Form 1116 it sits in the passive category, alongside UK bank interest and dividends. If UK tax on other passive income already exceeds the US tax on it, those excess credits can absorb some of the US tax on the award interest. Unused passive credits from other years carry ${FACTS.ftcCarry.v} years, as Publication 514 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) explains.
The treaty does not change this for a citizen. Interest is generally taxed by the country of residence, but the saving clause in the US-UK income tax treaty (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) lets the US tax its citizens as if the treaty did not exist, while Article 24 keeps the credit. The reverse case, UK tax on an item the US excludes, produces no US tax on that item to offset. The working order is:
- First. Split the award into its heads of loss and its interest periods, using the judgment or settlement document
- Second. Settle the UK position on post-judgment interest and investment income, including any reclaim of tax deducted
- Third. Report only the taxable US components, converted to dollars at the rate for the date received
- Fourth. Claim the UK tax you actually owe on the shared items on Form 1116, passive category
- Fifth. Check whether excess passive credits or carryovers cover the US tax on the UK-exempt interest
How the rules work for one claimant by role
Take a US citizen working as a physiotherapist in Leeds, struck by a car on a pedestrian crossing. She sues the driver's insurer, the court awards general damages, past and future loss of earnings, care costs and interest from the date of the accident, and the insurer pays some weeks after judgment.
On the UK side, almost nothing is taxable. The damages are covered by section 51(2), and the interest to judgment by section 751. The interest for the weeks between judgment and payment is taxable savings income and goes on her SA100 return through UK Self Assessment. She puts the balance in a UK savings account, and the interest on that is taxable in the usual way, under the usual Income Tax rates and allowances (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab).
On the US side, the damages and lost earnings stay off her return. She took the standard deduction in earlier years, so no medical recovery arises. Both slices of interest go on the return as interest income: the pre-judgment interest with no UK tax behind it, the post-judgment interest with whatever UK tax she owes on it credited on Form 1116. Our individual tax returns and treaty relief work handles both sides. A mis-selling payout has a different split, covered in our post on PPI and car finance compensation, and disability benefits paid alongside are in our post on UK benefits on a US return. The guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation shows where the credit fits.
General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.



