Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

Double tax reliefBy US UK Tax Returns9 Nov 20267 min read

PPI and car finance compensation: the interest on your US and UK returns

Man reads a compensation letter beside his car on a Midlands driveway, a PPI interest US tax question arriving by post

A redress letter usually splits a refund of charges from statutory interest, and only the interest, with any UK tax kept on it, belongs on the US return.

The statutory interest in a PPI or car finance payout is taxable savings income in the UK and gross income on a US return, but the refund of premiums and charges you paid is generally income in neither country. UK tax deducted from that interest supports a US foreign tax credit (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) only to the extent you could not reclaim it from HMRC, and that last point is the one most often missed.

This post is for US citizens and green card holders living in Britain who have received, or expect, a compensation letter from a bank, card issuer or car finance lender. It goes deeper than our guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation on one payment. It splits the letter into its parts, follows the interest through both returns, explains why a reclaimable deduction is not a creditable tax, and ends with a step-by-step process and a worked example.

Which parts of a PPI payout are taxable in the UK

Only the interest added to compensate you for being without your money. HMRC's Savings and Investment Manual says a PPI settlement usually has three parts: a refund of premiums, a refund of the historic interest charged on them, and simple statutory interest. The first two are refunds of amounts you paid and are not taxable.

The statutory interest is different. HMRC says it is taxable on the customer and must be declared, either to HMRC directly or on a Self Assessment return (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab). It is savings income, in the same family as bank interest. Income tax is deducted at source: the manual says anyone paying interest on any form of compensation to an individual must deduct tax from it, and lenders usually do so at the basic rate. The letter, or a separate certificate, should show the gross interest, the tax deducted and the net amount paid.

Car finance commission redress under the FCA's scheme also adds simple interest to compensation, and the scheme rules require lenders to tell you about any tax deducted. HMRC's worked examples are written for PPI, so treat the refund-and-interest split as the starting point for car finance and confirm it against the lender's breakdown. The scheme itself has faced legal challenges in the Upper Tribunal and the FCA has said payouts are delayed, so check its current position before relying on any timetable.

When can you reclaim the UK tax on the interest

When your allowances cover the interest. Whether you owe UK tax on savings income depends on your other income, because the starting rate for savings and the personal savings allowance can cover some or all of it. Where they do, the tax the lender deducted is an overpayment, and you can claim it back from HMRC.

HMRC sets your Personal Allowance (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) of £12,570 against wages or pension first. The starting rate for savings then shrinks as other income rises above it, and the personal savings allowance depends on your band: larger for a basic-rate taxpayer, smaller at the higher rate, and nothing at the additional rate. A one-off compensation payment counts toward your band in the year it is paid, which can push savings income past the allowance.

Outside Self Assessment, the claim is made on form R40, one form per tax year, for the current year and the four before it, with the lender's certificate of gross interest and tax deducted attached. HMRC keeps a separate postal address for PPI interest claims. If you are registered for Self Assessment, HMRC says you must use the tax return instead, where the deduction is set against your bill. Our UK Self Assessment team handles either route. The usual outcomes:

  • Interest fully inside your starting rate or savings allowance. The whole deduction is repayable
  • Interest partly inside your allowances. The excess deduction is repayable and the rest stands
  • Basic-rate taxpayer with allowances already used. The deduction usually matches the tax owed
  • Higher or additional-rate taxpayer. The deduction counts toward a larger bill settled through Self Assessment

Is PPI interest taxable on a US return

Yes. Publication 550 says any interest you receive, or that is credited to your account and can be withdrawn, is taxable income, and that you must report it even without a Form 1099-INT. Statutory interest from a UK lender goes on the US return for the year you receive it, converted into dollars.

Report the gross interest, before UK tax was taken off, and treat the deduction separately as foreign tax. The examples in Publication 514 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) include the full payment in income and treat the tax withheld as the foreign tax. Publication 550 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) also reminds US citizens that foreign investment income must be reported unless US law exempts it. The treaty does not help a citizen here: interest is generally taxed by the country of residence, but the saving clause in the US-UK treaty (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) lets the US tax its citizens regardless.

Publication 525 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) lists interest on any award as ordinary income and says interest on a recovery is reported as interest income in the year received. Because the source of interest follows the residence of the payer, interest from a UK lender is foreign source, and it falls in the passive category on Form 1116. Our individual tax returns service places it on the Form 1040 with the matching credit.

Is the refund of PPI premiums US income

Generally not. A refund of premiums, charges or loan interest you paid out of your own taxed money puts you back where you were and is not new income. The exception is a recovery: where you deducted the amount, or took a credit for it, in an earlier year and that reduced your tax, part of the refund can be taxable.

Publication 525 defines a recovery as a return of an amount you deducted or took a credit for in an earlier year, and includes it in income only up to the tax benefit the earlier deduction gave. The IRS treats personal interest, such as credit card interest and interest on older loans for a personal car, as non-deductible. For most people the refunded premiums and historic interest therefore never produced a US tax benefit and stay outside income.

The answer changes where the loan or card was used in a business. A self-employed American who deducted finance charges or PPI premiums as business expenses may have a taxable recovery when they come back. That needs the earlier returns checked year by year before the refund is left off, and our treaty relief review covers it alongside the interest.

Does UK tax on PPI interest count for the foreign tax credit

Only the part you genuinely owe. The Form 1116 instructions (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) bar a credit for tax you do not legally owe, including amounts eligible for refund by the foreign country, and for any excess you could have removed through available remedies. UK tax you could reclaim on form R40 or through Self Assessment is not creditable.

Publication 514 limits the credit to the legal and actual foreign tax liability, and excludes an amount that is reasonably certain to be refunded if you claimed it. The US credit therefore follows the UK answer. Work out your UK liability on the interest first, after your allowances. The creditable tax is that liability, which may be all of the deduction, part of it or none. For a higher-rate taxpayer, the further UK tax paid on the interest through Self Assessment counts as well.

The common error is crediting the full deduction on the US return and then collecting a refund from HMRC as well. Publication 514 treats a later refund of foreign tax as a redetermination, and where it changes your US tax you generally file Form 1040-X to tell the IRS. Our post on which UK taxes count for the credit covers creditability more widely.

How to handle a compensation letter step by step

Separate the payment into refund and interest, settle the UK tax on the interest, then report the gross interest in the US with a credit for the UK tax you actually owe. Working in that order stops the US return claiming a tax that HMRC later repays, and keeps both returns consistent.

The steps below assume a calendar-year US filer resident in the UK. A filer living abroad on the regular due date has the automatic extension (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) to 15 June, though interest on unpaid tax runs from 15 April.

Keep the lender's letter, the certificate of tax deducted, any HMRC repayment notice and the exchange rates you used in one place. The Form 1116 instructions ask for an explanation of how you figured the conversion rate, and an HMRC repayment that arrives after the US return is filed is the event that may require an amendment.

  • Get the breakdown. Premiums or charges refunded, historic interest refunded, gross statutory interest, tax deducted and net paid
  • Note the payment date. It fixes the UK tax year and the US calendar year
  • Work out the UK liability. Apply your starting rate and personal savings allowance to the interest
  • Reclaim or report in the UK. Form R40 outside Self Assessment, or the SA100 return by 31 January
  • Report the gross interest in the US. Convert it to dollars and enter it as foreign-source passive interest
  • Credit only the UK liability. Convert the tax at the rate on the day it was withheld and keep the certificate

How this works for a nurse in Leeds and her partner

Take a US citizen employed as a nurse in Leeds, a basic-rate taxpayer with little other savings income, and her partner, a US citizen paid at the higher rate. Each receives a PPI settlement for an old credit card, with statutory interest taxed at source. The same letter produces two different US credits.

The nurse's interest sits inside her personal savings allowance, so she owes no UK tax on it and the whole deduction is repayable. She is not in Self Assessment, so she sends form R40 with the lender's certificate. On her US return she reports the gross interest as passive income and claims no credit for the deduction, because it was never a legal liability. The premium refund is left out, since she never deducted the card charges.

Her partner has already used his smaller allowance on bank interest, so his deduction stands and a further amount is due on his Self Assessment return by 31 January. His creditable UK tax is the deduction plus that extra tax. If his UK tax on the interest exceeds the US tax on it, the excess credit can be carried back one year and forward ten years within the passive category. Our guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation shows how the passive category fits with the rest of the credit.

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

Avoiding US-UK Double Taxation: The Treaty, Foreign Tax Credits and the FEIE

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

Do I have to tell the IRS about PPI interest if HMRC already taxed it?

Yes, if you are a US citizen or green card holder. Interest is taxable on the US return whether or not a Form 1099-INT arrives, and UK tax taken at source does not remove it. You report the gross interest and claim a foreign tax credit for UK tax you actually owe on it, which usually prevents a second charge on the same money.

My PPI letter says tax was taken off the interest. Can I get it back from HMRC?

Often, if your starting rate for savings or personal savings allowance covers the interest. Outside Self Assessment you claim on form R40, one per tax year, with the lender's certificate of gross interest and tax deducted. If you file Self Assessment, HMRC says to use the tax return instead. Whatever you reclaim cannot also be credited on your US return.

Is car finance commission compensation taxable in the US?

The refund of commission or charges you paid is generally not income, because it returns your own money, unless you deducted those charges in an earlier year, for example in a business. Interest added to the compensation is taxable interest on your US return in the year you receive it, with a credit for any UK tax you genuinely owe on it.

Can I claim a foreign tax credit for PPI tax I have reclaimed from HMRC?

No. The IRS allows a credit only for foreign tax you legally owe, and the Form 1116 instructions exclude amounts eligible for refund by the foreign country. If you claimed the credit and HMRC repays the tax later, that is a foreign tax redetermination, and you generally amend the US return on Form 1040-X where it changes your US tax.

The interest on my payout covers several years. Which year does it go on my US return?

Generally the year you receive it. Publication 550 treats interest as income when it is received or credited to your account and can be withdrawn, and Publication 525 says interest on a recovery is reported in the year received. It does not matter that the interest was calculated over many years of the original loan or card agreement.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us