Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

Double tax reliefBy US UK Tax Returns10 Nov 20267 min read

Carer's Allowance, PIP and Universal Credit on a US tax return

Daughter and her elderly mother read a brown envelope together on a sofa, a UK benefits US tax return question

A carer helping a parent with a benefits letter may never think of the IRS, yet for a US citizen in Britain the US treatment of that payment turns on domestic law, not the treaty.

For a US citizen or green card holder living in Britain, the treaty does not take UK benefits off a US tax return. The social security paragraph in the US-UK income tax treaty (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) only covers payments sent across the border, so a UK benefit paid to a UK resident falls back on US domestic law. Carer's Allowance is taxable in both countries, with a credit for the UK tax. For PIP, Attendance Allowance, Disability Living Allowance and Universal Credit, the US position is not settled, and each needs a recorded decision.

This post is for Americans in the UK who claim a working-age or disability benefit, and for the families who help them file. It goes deeper than our guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation on one group of payments. Pensions are covered elsewhere: see our posts on the UK State Pension on a US return and US Social Security for UK residents. Here we take the treaty, then each benefit, then a recording process and an example.

How are UK benefits treated on a US tax return

Start from the US rule that a citizen or green card holder is taxed on worldwide income, then ask two questions for each payment. First, does any treaty article stop the US taxing it. Second, if not, does US domestic law treat it as gross income. For UK residents, the second question does most of the work.

The UK side is simpler, because HMRC publishes the answer. Its page on taxable and tax-free state benefits (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) lists Carer's Allowance, contribution-based Employment and Support Allowance and Jobseeker's Allowance as taxable. Personal Independence Payment, Attendance Allowance, Disability Living Allowance, Universal Credit, income-related Employment and Support Allowance and Child Benefit appear on the tax-free list, with Child Benefit subject to the separate high income charge.

That UK split does not carry over to the US return. A benefit HMRC leaves untaxed brings no UK tax to credit, so if the US treats it as income, US tax can be due with nothing to offset it. A benefit HMRC taxes can usually be relieved by the foreign tax credit (opens the official IRS page in a new tab). The order of work therefore matters: settle the UK answer, then decide the US character of each payment.

Does the US-UK treaty exempt UK benefits for a US citizen

Not for a UK resident. Article 17(3) gives payments made under one country's social security or similar legislation to a resident of the other country to that other country alone. A UK benefit paid to someone living in the UK is not paid to a resident of the other country, so the paragraph never applies.

The saving clause in Article 1(4) then lets the US tax its citizens as if the treaty had not come into effect. Article 1(5)(a) protects Article 17(3) from that clause, which is why US Social Security paid to a UK resident escapes US tax, but the protection only helps where the paragraph applies in the first place. Article 22, on income not dealt with elsewhere, gives the country of residence the right to tax, yet it is not on the Article 1(5) list, so it does not bind the US for its own citizens.

What survives is Article 24, which requires the US to credit UK income tax paid by its citizens and is itself protected from the saving clause. The Treasury technical explanation (opens the official US Treasury page in a new tab) says the phrase similar legislation is meant to reach US Tier 1 railroad benefits. It says nothing on whether means-tested or disability payments count as social security, a point that matters mainly for someone resident in the US who still receives a UK payment.

Is Carer's Allowance taxable in the US

Yes, in our view, and it is the easiest of the group. Carer's Allowance is taxable in the UK, its GOV.UK conditions include no savings test, and it is hard to fit within the US welfare exclusion described below. It goes on the US return as income, with a credit for any UK income tax you pay on it.

GOV.UK sets the conditions: at least 35 hours of care a week and earnings under a weekly limit after tax, National Insurance and expenses. That earnings test is a condition of entitlement rather than a test of household need. Publication 915 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) says foreign social security benefits are taxable as annuities unless a treaty exempts them, and no treaty article exempts a UK resident. Whether you label it a foreign social security benefit or other income, it is gross income.

Relief comes from the UK tax actually paid. Where your personal allowance of £12,570 absorbs the allowance, there may be no UK tax and no credit, but the income still belongs on the US return. Where UK tax is due, it is creditable on Form 1116 under Article 24, and our individual tax returns service matches the two figures across both returns.

Are PIP, Attendance Allowance and DLA taxable in the US

The official texts do not settle it. These are UK disability payments that HMRC does not tax, and no IRS publication we have read addresses them. Two readings of US domestic law are open, and which one fits a household depends on the facts. Whichever you adopt, apply it every year and record why.

The first reading starts from Publication 525 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab), which tells filers not to include governmental benefit payments from a public welfare fund based upon need. On this view, PIP, Attendance Allowance and DLA are public payments that meet the extra costs of disability, and need is measured by the claimant's condition. The weak point is that the IRS describes need in financial terms, and GOV.UK says PIP can be paid even to someone who is working or has savings.

The second reading treats them as foreign social security benefits, which Publication 915 makes taxable as annuities, or simply as gross income with no exclusion to rely on. Its weak point is that these benefits are not paid for past contributions or work. Our treaty relief team sets out both readings against the claimant's facts before the return is prepared. Points that bear on the choice:

  • Who the claimant is. A benefit paid to a parent or spouse who is not a US person does not belong on your return
  • What the payment funds. Care and mobility costs linked to disability support the welfare reading
  • Whether income or savings matter. PIP ignores both, which weakens the need argument
  • Consistency across years. Switching readings without a change in facts invites questions

Is Universal Credit income for US tax purposes

Probably not, though this too is not settled. Universal Credit is paid to people on a low income, it reduces as income rises and it has a savings limit. That matches the need test in the IRS welfare language more closely than any other benefit here, but no IRS source confirms that the doctrine reaches a foreign government's fund.

The argument for exclusion is that Publication 525 describes payments from a public welfare fund based upon need and says nothing to confine the fund to a US one. The argument against is that the exclusion is administrative rather than statutory, and Publication 915 treats foreign social security benefits as taxable unless a treaty exempts them. If Universal Credit is that kind of benefit, the annuity rule applies and nothing in the treaty removes it for a UK resident.

Two points apply whichever view you take. Publication 525 says welfare payments that are compensation for services, or obtained by fraud, are taxable, so a work-related element needs checking. And Child Benefit (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) raises the same question with less support for exclusion, because GOV.UK sets no general income or savings test for claiming it, and higher earners repay it through the separate charge instead. Our post on which UK taxes count for the credit covers that charge.

How to record a position on each UK benefit

Treat each benefit separately, record the reading you adopt with your reasons, and keep the award letters with your US records. A position that is written down and applied consistently is far easier to explain to the IRS than a payment that appears in one year and disappears the next.

The steps below assume a calendar-year US filer resident in the UK. Filers abroad on the regular due date have the automatic extension (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) to 15 June, though interest on unpaid tax runs from 15 April. Benefit years do not follow either tax year, so total each payment by calendar year from the award letters or the bank statements that show each deposit.

Form 8833 is the form for treaty-based return positions under section 6114. Because none of the readings above relies on a treaty article to override US law, the disclosure question generally does not arise here. Our post on Form 8833 explains when it does. Statutory Sick Pay sits outside this list altogether, since GOV.UK says the employer pays it like normal wages with tax and National Insurance deducted.

  • List every payment. Name the benefit, who receives it and the calendar-year total in pounds
  • Check HMRC's list. Mark each benefit as taxable or tax-free in the UK
  • Confirm the treaty does not apply. For a UK resident, Article 17(3) does not engage
  • Choose a US reading. Income, or excluded under the welfare doctrine, with reasons noted
  • Convert and report. Enter taxable amounts in dollars on the Form 1040
  • Credit only UK tax paid. Taxable benefits only, on Form 1116

How this works for a carer in Cardiff

Take a US citizen living in Cardiff who cares for her British mother full time. She receives Carer's Allowance and Universal Credit. Her mother, who is not a US person, receives Attendance Allowance. Three benefits arrive in one household, and each ends up in a different place on the US return.

The Carer's Allowance is US income. Her small earnings and the allowance sit inside her UK personal allowance, so no UK tax arises and there is nothing to credit. She reports it in dollars on her Form 1040. Filing separately from her non-US husband, she faces the $5 filing threshold, so a return is due even in a low-income year.

Her Universal Credit is the judgement call. She adopts the welfare reading, excludes it and keeps a note setting out the need test and the savings limit. Her mother's Attendance Allowance never touches her return. Any UK tax she later pays on Carer's Allowance through UK Self Assessment by 31 January can be credited, and our guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation shows how that credit fits with her other income.

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

Avoiding US-UK Double Taxation: The Treaty, Foreign Tax Credits and the FEIE

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

I get PIP and live in England. Do I have to declare it to the IRS?

There is no settled answer. HMRC does not tax PIP, and the US-UK treaty does not exempt it for a UK resident. Whether it is US income depends on whether you treat it as a need-based welfare payment, which the IRS excludes, or as a taxable foreign benefit. Pick a reading with advice, apply it every year and keep a note of your reasons.

Can I use the foreign earned income exclusion for Carer's Allowance?

We would not rely on it. The exclusion covers pay for personal services, and Carer's Allowance is paid by the state rather than earned from an employer or a business. The usual route is to report it as income and claim a foreign tax credit for any UK income tax you pay on it. If no UK tax is due, there is nothing to credit.

Does Article 17(3) of the treaty protect my Universal Credit?

No, not while you live in the UK. Article 17(3) covers social security payments made by one country to a resident of the other. Universal Credit paid by the UK to a UK resident is outside it. Whether Universal Credit is US income is a domestic law question, and the strongest argument for leaving it out is the IRS exclusion for need-based public welfare payments.

My mother gets Attendance Allowance and I manage it for her. Is it on my US return?

Generally no. The benefit belongs to the person entitled to it, and acting for her does not make it your income. If your mother is not a US citizen or green card holder, it has no place on any US return. If she is a US person, the question of whether it is US income arises on her own return instead.

Is Statutory Sick Pay treated like a UK benefit on my US return?

Not usually. GOV.UK says your employer pays Statutory Sick Pay in the same way as normal wages, with tax and National Insurance deducted. It therefore sits with your salary, the UK tax on it is part of the tax on your earnings, and it follows the same foreign tax credit or exclusion treatment you use for the rest of your pay.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us