Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

Companies and equityBy US UK Tax Returns12 Nov 20268 min read

Your UK company paying for your US tax return: the tax for a US citizen director

Director in a London office checking an accountant invoice the UK company may pay for a US tax return

Whose name is on the invoice, and how the company pays it, decides the tax on both sides of the Atlantic.

When a UK company pays the fees for its director's personal US return, FBAR and UK Self Assessment, both countries normally treat the payment as part of the director's pay. HMRC sees earnings or a benefit, reported through payroll or on form P11D, and the IRS sees compensation that belongs on the director's Form 1040 under the fringe benefit rules in Publication 525 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab). Neither side offers a general exemption for personal tax compliance fees, so the real decision is how the payment is arranged, not whether it escapes tax.

This post is for US citizens and green card holders who own and run a UK limited company and would like it to settle their adviser's invoice. It goes further than our guide to US-UK tax for founders, fund managers and executives on one recurring cost. It covers the UK reporting routes, corporation tax, the loan account alternative, the US treatment, Form 5471 and what to settle before anything is paid. Pay strategy more widely is in our post on salary or dividends for a US founder.

Is a company paying a director's personal tax return fees a taxable benefit

Generally yes. Preparing a director's own tax returns is a personal service, so when the company bears the cost it gives the director something of value because of the job. GOV.UK treats personal bills met by an employer as taxable, and we found no exemption in HMRC's Employment Income Manual for personal return fees.

The starting point is what HMRC's manual at EIM00580 calls the pecuniary liability principle. If a bill is legally yours and your employer settles it, your debt has been discharged, and the amount counts as earnings because it arises from the employment. It makes no difference whether the employer pays voluntarily or because a contract requires it. A US return, FBAR and Self Assessment prepared under an engagement letter in your own name fit that pattern closely.

Some advice is exempt, but none of it fits here. HMRC's manual describes a relief for pensions advice provided by employers, and that relief is confined to pensions. Helpsheet HS207 carves advice on finance or tax out of the welfare counselling exemption. Where an employer meets an employee's tax itself under a tax equalisation arrangement, HMRC's manual treats the payment as further earnings, so equalisation is a cost to plan for, not a way out.

Should the fees go through payroll or on the P11D

That depends on who signs the engagement and who pays. GOV.UK sets out three routes for an employee's personal bills: the company contracts and pays, the employee contracts and the company pays the supplier, or the employee pays and is reimbursed. Each carries different PAYE, National Insurance and reporting results.

The difference matters more than it first appears. Class 1A is a charge on the employer alone, so on the first route nothing comes out of the director's pay, although the director still owes income tax on the benefit, usually collected through Self Assessment or a change to the tax code. Where the engagement letter is in the director's name, HMRC's manual at EIM00590 explains that PAYE cannot be operated on a direct payment of the employee's debt, which is why the income tax follows the P11D while National Insurance goes through payroll.

Some companies payroll benefits instead of filing a P11D, and HMRC has announced a move towards mandatory payrolling for certain benefits, so check which method applies for the year. Whichever method is used, the figure is generally the cost to the company. Our payroll services team sets up the treatment within the company's PAYE and benefits reporting (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) so it matches the engagement letter.

  • Company engages and pays the adviser: P11D, with Class 1A paid by the company
  • Director engages, company pays the adviser: P11D for income tax, Class 1 through payroll
  • Director pays, company reimburses: treated as pay, with PAYE and Class 1 through payroll
  • Director pays and is not reimbursed: no benefit and no company expense

Can the company deduct the fees for corporation tax

Usually, where the payment is treated as part of the director's remuneration. HMRC's Business Income Manual says pay and benefits for directors and employees are normally allowable because they are incurred for the trade, though HMRC can examine the purpose behind an unusual payment. A personal fee booked as a company cost with no benefit reported invites questions.

A familiar pattern runs like this: one invoice arrives, the bookkeeper posts it to accountancy, and nobody records the director's share. HMRC may then argue both that the personal element was not incurred wholly and exclusively for the trade and that a benefit went unreported. Our business tax returns service prepares the corporation tax (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) computation with the split already made.

Where the company bears the fee and reports it as a benefit, it sits in the accounts as a staff cost. Where the director repays the company, there is neither a benefit nor a company expense, because the payment becomes a balance the director owes.

What if the fees go through the director's loan account

Then the director, not the company, bears the cost. The company pays the adviser and debits the director's loan account, and the director clears the balance from salary or dividends that have already been taxed. Nothing is reported as a benefit for the fees themselves, but an overdrawn account brings its own UK and US rules.

GOV.UK's guidance on director's loans explains that where a director who is also a shareholder still owes the company money a set period after the end of an accounting period, the company pays a temporary corporation tax charge, shown on form CT600A and reclaimable once the loan is repaid. A larger balance can also create a benefit in kind on the interest-free loan, and a loan that is written off is taxed as income. Check the thresholds and rates on GOV.UK for the year concerned.

For a close company, UK law extends the meaning of a distribution to benefits provided to shareholders. HMRC's Company Taxation Manual at CTM60600 says that extension should normally be treated as not applying to benefits for a director, so for a working director the choice is usually between earnings and a loan, not a deemed dividend. On the US side, a loan from a controlled foreign corporation to its US shareholder raises a separate question, covered in our post on borrowing from your UK company.

How does the IRS treat fees your UK company pays for you

As compensation. Publication 525 says fringe benefits received for your services are income unless you pay fair market value or the law specifically excludes them. No exclusion covers personal tax preparation, so fees your company pays for you belong in the wages reported on your Form 1040, alongside your UK salary.

The IRS has closed the obvious doors. Publication 15-B (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) lets employers exclude retirement planning advice but states that the exclusion does not reach tax preparation, accounting, legal or brokerage services. The working condition exclusion applies only to costs the employee could deduct as a business expense, and preparing your personal return is not part of doing your job as a director. In Chief Counsel Advice 201810007, which is not precedent, the IRS concluded that an employer's tax preparation for staff working abroad was income to them at its fair market value.

A UK company does not issue Form W-2, so the figure comes from the payslips and P11D, converted to dollars. Publication 54 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) lists amounts an employer pays to a third party on your behalf among employer-provided amounts, which makes the fees foreign earned income. With the foreign tax credit (opens the official IRS page in a new tab), UK income tax on the benefit sits with the tax on your salary; Class 1A is the company's charge, not yours. With the exclusion on Form 2555, the fees form part of the earnings tested against the limit.

How do the fees show on Form 5471

If you control the company, the fees form part of its expenses on Form 5471, restated under US tax principles. Treated as your pay, they are a compensation cost of the company. Run through your loan account, they become a balance you owe the company, which is a related-party item the form also captures.

The Instructions for Form 5471 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) require a category 4 filer to complete Schedule M, which reports transactions between the company and its US shareholders during the year. A company that pays bills for its controlling shareholder, or carries a balance that person owes, has transactions to consider for that schedule. The income statement and balance sheet on the form should follow the treatment chosen in the UK, so a fee the P11D treats as pay is not presented on Form 5471 as a loan.

Consistency between the two countries is the whole point. Our post on Form 5471 for a one-person UK limited company explains the categories and schedules, and the Form 5471 page lists the information the company's accountant will be asked for.

Worked example: a US citizen director in Bristol

A US citizen in Bristol owns all the shares in a UK consultancy and is its only director. Her adviser prepares her Form 1040, FBAR and Self Assessment each year and, separately, the company's accounts and corporation tax return. Until now a single combined invoice has gone to the company and been posted to accountancy, with nothing on her P11D.

From this year she decides the route before the work starts. The company engages the adviser for her personal returns and pays directly, the personal work is invoiced separately, and the cost goes on her P11D with Class 1A paid by the company. She pays income tax on the benefit through her Self Assessment, filed by 31 January, and the company deducts the cost as part of her remuneration. Her FBAR goes to FinCEN rather than the IRS and is due 15 April, extended automatically to 15 October. It is a personal report, so its preparation sits on the same personal invoice; our page on FBAR filing explains what it covers.

On her US return the fees join her wages for the calendar year in which the company paid them, and she claims the foreign tax credit for the UK tax on the whole package. On Form 5471 they are a compensation cost, matching the P11D. She files by 15 June under the automatic extension for taxpayers abroad. Our individual tax returns and UK Self Assessment services prepare both returns, and the founders guide covers the rest of a director's pay.

  • Choose the route: company benefit, director engagement, reimbursement or loan account
  • Address the engagement letter and invoice to match that choice
  • Ask for personal US, FBAR and UK work to be billed apart from company work
  • Record the payment in payroll, on the P11D or in the loan account at the time
  • Give your US preparer the payslips, P11D and loan account statement for the year

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

US-UK Tax for Founders, Fund Managers and Executives

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

Can my company just pay my accountant and put it through as a business expense?

It can pay, but the personal part is not a plain business expense. Fees for your own returns are a benefit or earnings for you in the UK and compensation on your US return. If the company reports the benefit, the cost is usually deductible as remuneration. If it reports nothing, HMRC can challenge the deduction and the missing benefit, and your Form 1040 would understate your wages.

Is there a small amount my company can pay towards my tax return without it being taxed?

We found no threshold for personal tax return fees in HMRC's manual. The trivial benefits exemption has its own conditions, including a cost limit and a rule that the benefit is not a reward for work or provided under your contract, and a regular annual professional fee will rarely meet them. In the US there is no equivalent relief for tax preparation, so the fee is pay.

My return only needs Form 5471 because I own the company. Is that part a company cost?

Form 5471 is filed by you as a US shareholder, attached to your own return, so the obligation is personal even though the form describes the company. Expect HMRC and the IRS to see that cost like the rest of your return. Work that is genuinely the company's, such as its accounts and corporation tax return, is a company cost. Ask for an itemised invoice and take advice on any split.

My company paid last year's fees and nothing was reported. How do I put it right?

Correct both sides. In the UK the company may need to file or amend a P11D and pay Class 1A, or record the fees in your loan account if that matches what was agreed at the time. In the US an amended return on Form 1040-X adds the fees to wages, and the related UK income tax can usually be added to your foreign tax credit claim.

Does the same treatment apply to a green card holder who lives in the UK?

Broadly yes. A green card holder is generally taxed by the US on worldwide income in the same way as a citizen, so employer-paid fees are compensation on the Form 1040. The UK treatment turns on being a director or employee of the company, not on nationality. A treaty tie-breaker claim can change the US position, so take advice before filing on that basis.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us