Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

Double tax reliefBy US UK Tax Returns14 Nov 20267 min read

Teachers', council and police pensions: how the US-UK treaty taxes UK public service pensions

Retired teacher carries flowers and a box out of a school gate, a UK public service pension US tax treaty case

Leaving a classroom career brings a Teachers' Pension, and whether the treaty treats it as government service depends on who pays it and on the retiree's citizenship.

Under the UK public service pension US tax treaty rule in Article 19(2), pensions from the civil service, the armed forces, the police, the fire service, local authorities and state-school teaching are government pensions. They are taxable only in the UK unless the pensioner is both resident in and a national of the United States. Most NHS pensions sit outside the article. For a US citizen, the saving clause in the US-UK income tax treaty (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) lets the US tax either kind, with a credit for the UK tax.

This post is for anyone holding a UK public sector pension who also has a US connection: a US citizen living in Britain, a dual national, or a British national weighing a move across the Atlantic. Our guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation gives the general pension rules. Here we sort the schemes one by one using HMRC's own classification, then show why the label matters far more for some people than for others.

Which UK public sector pensions count as government pensions

HMRC keeps a list in its International Manual. Civil service, armed forces, police, local authority and general teachers' pensions are government pensions, as are fire service pensions paid by a local authority or under the Firefighters' Pension Scheme. NHS pensions paid by the NHS Business Services Authority are not, and neither are teachers' pensions from private schools.

The list is more detailed than most people expect. On the government side it names the Metropolitan Police Fund and Transport Police alongside ordinary police forces, the devolved administrations in Scotland and Northern Ireland, and smaller bodies such as the Forestry Commission and the British Museum. The non-government side includes the Bank of England, the Post Office, the Environment Agency and the Universities Superannuation Scheme, which covers many university staff.

Two NHS entries need care. A pension paid by the NHS Business Services Authority, Capita, the Paymaster General's Office or the Scottish Public Pensions Agency is non-government. An NHS pension paid by a local authority is listed as a government pension. HMRC also flags that Capita, a private company, pays some public sector pensions, and says claims showing it as payer need careful handling.

  • Government (Article 19). Civil service, armed forces, police, fire service, local authority, teachers in state schools
  • Government (Article 19). NHS pensions paid by a local authority, and the devolved governments' own schemes
  • Non-government (Article 17). NHS pensions paid by the NHS Business Services Authority or the Scottish Public Pensions Agency
  • Non-government (Article 17). Universities Superannuation Scheme, private and independent school teachers, the Post Office, the Bank of England
  • Not listed. Academy trusts and employers admitted to a council pension fund: ask HMRC before relying on either article

What does Article 19(2) say about who taxes the pension

Article 19(2) covers pensions paid by, or out of funds created by, a State, a political subdivision or a local authority, for services rendered to it. Sub-paragraph (a) gives such a pension to the paying country alone. Sub-paragraph (b) reverses that where the pensioner is both resident in and a national of the other country.

The paragraph opens by overriding paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 17, the general pension article, so a government pension never reaches the residence-country rule that applies to private schemes. The wording is on GOV.UK's copy of the 2001 convention as amended (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab). Article 19(3) then carves out pensions for service in a business carried on by a State or local authority and sends them back to the ordinary articles, which fits the listing of trading bodies such as the Post Office as non-government.

The Treasury technical explanation (opens the official US Treasury page in a new tab) adds two points. Pensions of retired civilian and military government employees are intended to fall under Article 19(2). Benefits paid in the form of social security, even if linked to government service, stay under Article 17, so a former police officer's UK State Pension follows the social security rule, not the government one. The mirror rule for American federal service is in our post on US government employees in the UK.

How does Article 17 treat a private or NHS pension instead

Article 17(1)(a) gives a pension to the country where the owner lives. A UK resident is taxed on it by the UK; a US resident by the US. Article 17(2) sends lump sums from a pension scheme to the country where the scheme is established. Government pensions are lifted out of both paragraphs by Article 19(2).

The practical difference shows up when someone moves. A British national holding an NHS pension paid by the NHS Business Services Authority who retires to Florida is taxed on it by the US alone. A former council planning officer in the same position keeps paying UK tax, because Article 19(2)(a) leaves the pension with the UK unless she also becomes a US national. Private schemes follow the owner; government schemes stay put.

Lump sums are a separate and unsettled question. The technical explanation confirms that Article 17(2) is subject to the saving clause for US citizens, and our post on whether a UK pension lump sum is taxable in the US sets out the competing readings. How a periodic pension is taxed on the US return, once it is taxable there, is covered in Publication 575 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab).

Does the saving clause leave a US citizen any Article 19 protection

No. Article 1(4) lets the US tax its citizens and residents as if the treaty had not come into effect. Article 1(5)(b) preserves Article 19 only for people who are neither US citizens nor admitted for permanent residence, so a US citizen or green card holder gets nothing from the government service article.

The technical explanation is direct on this: a pension paid by the UK government for services to it is taxable only in the UK unless the individual is a US citizen or acquires a green card. What survives for citizens is Article 24, the double taxation relief article, which Article 1(5)(a) keeps. The UK tax deducted through PAYE is therefore credited against the US tax on the pension on Form 1116 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab), within the limits explained in Publication 514 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab).

In practice, a US citizen living in Britain with a teachers' or police pension is taxed by both countries, with the credit usually removing most or all of the US tax because UK rates are generally higher. Unused credit carries back one year and forward ten years within its category. Earlier working years raise different questions, which our posts on catching up as a UK civil servant and catching up as a UK teacher cover.

UK public service pension US tax treaty outcomes: a decision table

Three facts settle the answer: whether the pension is on HMRC's government list, which country you live in, and whether you are a US citizen or green card holder. For a US citizen, the label changes little while you live in Britain. For a British national, it decides which country taxes the pension after a move.

The table assumes a pension on HMRC's government list and a single country of treaty residence. In the year of a move, Article 4 decides residence first, and the saving clause explainer lists every benefit that survives for citizens. British nationals retiring to America will find the claim process in our post on retiring from Britain to the US.

  • British national only, living in the UK. UK taxes under Article 19(2)(a); no US interest
  • British national only, living in the US without a green card. UK taxes; the US exempts, kept by Article 1(5)(b)
  • British national only, holding a green card. UK taxes; the US also taxes and credits the UK tax under Article 24
  • US citizen only, living in the UK. UK taxes under Article 19(2)(a); the US taxes too, with a credit
  • US citizen only, living in the US. Resident and national of the US, so Article 19(2)(b) gives it to the US alone
  • Dual US and UK citizen in the UK. Same as a US citizen in the UK: both tax, with a US credit
  • Dual US and UK citizen in the US. Article 19(2)(b) applies; the US taxes alone and the UK exempts on a claim

How the rules play out for one household by role

Take a couple in Norwich. She is a US citizen only and a retired primary teacher who spent her career in council-maintained schools, so she draws a Teachers' Pension. He holds both passports and is a retired paramedic whose NHS pension is paid by the NHS Business Services Authority. Both are UK resident.

Today the two pensions reach the same place by different routes. Hers is a government pension, taxable in the UK under Article 19(2)(a). His is a private-type pension, taxable in the UK as the country of residence under Article 17(1)(a). Because both are US citizens, the saving clause lets the US tax both. Each reports the pension on Form 1040, credits the PAYE deducted on Form 1116, and handles any wider UK reporting on an SA100 return where one is needed.

Suppose they later move to Oregon. She becomes resident in the country of which she is a national, so Article 19(2)(b) gives her pension to the US alone. His NHS pension moves to the US under Article 17(1)(a). Both then ask HMRC to stop deducting tax, using the claim route our retirement post describes. A British-only friend, a retired firefighter moving with them on a green card, would not be so lucky: Article 19(2)(a) keeps his pension in the UK and the US taxes it as well.

Our US-UK pensions service checks each scheme against HMRC's list, our treaty relief work handles the claims, and individual tax returns brings both sides together. The treaty summary and the guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation show where Article 19 sits among the other reliefs.

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

Avoiding US-UK Double Taxation: The Treaty, Foreign Tax Credits and the FEIE

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

I taught at an academy rather than a council school. Is my Teachers' Pension a government pension?

HMRC's list names general teachers' pensions as government pensions and pensions for service at private or independent schools as non-government, but it does not mention academy trusts. The treaty test is whether the pension is paid by, or out of funds created by, the State or a local authority for services rendered to it. Where the answer is unclear, ask HMRC to confirm the classification before relying on Article 19 or Article 17.

Is my USS pension from a university lecturing job treated like a council pension?

No. HMRC lists the Universities Superannuation Scheme as non-government, so it falls under Article 17 rather than Article 19. For a British national, that means the pension follows residence and would be taxed only in the US after a move there. For a US citizen in the UK, the result is the same as for a government pension: both countries tax it and the US credits the UK tax.

I'm a dual citizen retiring to the US. Will HMRC keep taxing my police pension?

Not once you are treaty resident in the US. Article 19(2)(b) gives a government pension to the other country alone where the pensioner is both resident in and a national of it, and a US citizen is a US national whatever other passport they hold. HMRC does not stop PAYE automatically, though. You need to make a claim, certified by the IRS, and report the pension on your US return.

Does my State Pension follow Article 19 because I spent my career in public service?

No. The Treasury technical explanation says benefits paid in the form of social security are covered by Article 17 even where they relate to government service. The UK State Pension is therefore taxed by the country where you live under the social security paragraph, which survives the saving clause. Only the occupational pension from your public employer is tested against Article 19.

My pension statement shows Capita as the payer. Does that make it a private pension?

Not on its own. HMRC notes that Capita is a private company that pays some public sector pensions and asks its staff to handle such claims carefully. For NHS pensions, HMRC lists payment by Capita as non-government. For other schemes, the classification turns on the scheme and the service behind it, so confirm with HMRC before claiming treaty relief on either basis.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us