Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

Catch-upBy US UK Tax Returns8 Nov 20268 min read

Behind on US taxes as a teacher in a UK school: what the catch-up involves

Teacher marks exercise books in an empty classroom, a US citizen teacher with UK taxes and US filings to catch up

A teacher's PAYE salary is usually taxed in full in Britain, which is why the US catch-up is often more paperwork than tax.

For a US citizen teacher, UK taxes paid through PAYE do not end the US filing duty. Someone who has never filed usually catches up through the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures (opens the official IRS page in a new tab): returns for three years, FBARs for six years, a signed certification and any tax and interest. For most classroom teachers the UK tax on the salary covers the US tax, so the cost is mainly the work. The treaty's teachers article does not change that.

This post is for Americans who have taught for years in English, Scottish or Welsh schools, on permanent or supply contracts, and who have filed no US returns or FBARs. It sits beneath our guide for people behind on US taxes in the UK and deals with what is particular to teaching: the visiting teacher rule people misread, three different years that never line up, the teachers' pension, and whether a PAYE teacher needs any UK return.

Does the treaty's teachers article exempt a US citizen teaching in the UK

No. Article 20A of the US-UK treaty (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) exempts a visiting teacher's pay only in the country being visited, only for up to two years, and only where the teacher was resident in the other country immediately before arriving. It never removes a US citizen's salary from US tax.

The article, added by the 2002 protocol, sits after Article 20 on students. The Treasury Technical Explanation (opens the official US Treasury page in a new tab) describes a professor or teacher who visits for no more than two years to teach or research at a university, college or other recognised educational institution. If the stay runs past two years, the exemption is lost retroactively, the first two years included. A teacher who has been here for several years is outside it on that ground alone.

For a US citizen there is a second barrier. Article 1(4) lets the United States tax its citizens as if the treaty had not come into effect. The Technical Explanation reads Article 1(5)(b), after the protocol, as keeping the teachers article only for people who are neither citizens nor permanent residents of the taxing state, and gives the example of a US citizen living in the UK who visits the US to teach: no US exemption. Our post on the treaty saving clause explains it.

What does the Streamlined catch-up cover for a teacher

Under the Foreign route a teacher files US returns for the most recent three years whose due dates have passed, FBARs for the most recent six years, an original signed Form 14653, and payment of any tax and interest. Where the conditions are met, the IRS charges no failure-to-file, failure-to-pay, information return or FBAR penalties for those years.

The conditions come from the Streamlined procedures (opens the official IRS page in a new tab). A US citizen needs no US abode and at least 330 full days outside the United States in at least one of the three return years, which a teacher working in Britain usually meets. The failures must be non-wilful, meaning negligence, inadvertence, mistake or a good faith misunderstanding of the law. The route closes once the IRS opens a civil examination, and a valid Social Security number is needed before anything is sent.

The returns go on paper, each marked Streamlined Foreign Offshore in red at the top of the first page, with a copy of Form 14653 attached. The FBARs are not posted with them. They are filed electronically with FinCEN, giving the late filing reason as other and noting that they form part of the Streamlined procedures. A FinCEN Form 114 is due for any year in which your accounts together passed $10,000, counting accounts you could sign on as well as your own.

Our post on writing the non-wilful certification covers Form 14653, and our IRS streamlined filing service prepares the whole package.

Which documents does a teacher need for the catch-up

Payslips, P60s and pension statements for the return years, account statements for the FBAR years, and evidence of where you were. The payslips matter most, because three different years run through a teacher's records and only one of them, the calendar year, is the US tax year.

Pay scales follow the academic year from September, PAYE the UK tax year from 6 April, and the US return the calendar year. A P60 straddles two US years. Each US year is built from monthly payslips, or the pay history in the payroll portal, taking the months paid in that calendar year. Wages generally belong to the year in which they are paid or made available to you, so a pay award backdated to September counts in the year the arrears arrive.

Supply teachers have more to gather. Agency work on PAYE is wages in the same way, but records scatter, so keep each P45 and final payslip. Private tutoring paid directly to you is self-employment, covered in the questions below.

  • Monthly payslips for the three US years, or the payroll portal history
  • P60s and any P45s, to reconcile the UK tax deducted
  • Annual benefit statements and contribution history from the teachers' pension scheme
  • Bank, savings and ISA statements showing each account's highest balance for six years
  • Passport records or school calendars showing time spent outside the US
  • Your Social Security number and any FATCA letters from UK banks

How is the teachers' pension treated on the US return

In two stages. While you teach, the question is whether contributions and the yearly build-up of benefit can be left out of US income, which turns on Article 18(5) of the treaty. Once the pension is paid, the UK taxes it as your country of residence and the saving clause lets the US tax it too.

The Teachers' Pension Scheme in England and Wales is a statutory, unfunded defined benefit scheme: members build up a pension calculated from their pay, not an invested pot. Article 18(5) treats a UK-resident US citizen's contributions, and benefits accrued, as outside US taxable income only so far as they qualify for UK relief, only up to what a generally corresponding US plan would allow, and only if the US competent authority has agreed that the scheme generally corresponds to a US plan. We check that last condition for each case. Our post on contributions under Article 18 sets out the tests, and a treaty position is generally disclosed on Form 8833.

Public service status does not make the pension exempt for a citizen. Article 19(2), on pensions paid for services to a state or local authority, appears in the Article 1(5)(b) list, so it gives a US citizen nothing. Article 24 on relief from double taxation is in the list the saving clause leaves intact, which is why UK tax on the pension in payment is generally creditable against the US tax on it.

FBAR treatment of a defined benefit scheme is unsettled; our post on whether a UK pension is reportable on the FBAR sets out the views, and our US-UK pensions service reviews these points.

Does the foreign tax credit usually clear US tax on a teaching salary

Usually, yes. Income tax deducted through PAYE is an income tax paid to a foreign country, so it can be set against the US tax on the same salary on Form 1116. With UK rates on employment income generally higher than US rates, the credit tends to cover the US tax on wages, though the result depends on the figures.

IRS guidance on the foreign tax credit (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) limits the credit to income-type taxes imposed on you and allows no credit for tax on income you have excluded. That is why the credit, rather than the foreign earned income exclusion, is the usual choice for a PAYE teacher: excluding the salary would waste the UK tax paid on it. Unused credit can generally be carried back one year and forward ten.

Where US tax appears, it is usually not on the salary. Interest and fund income inside an ISA is taxable in the US with no UK tax to credit, and funds held there are commonly passive foreign investment companies. Tutoring income can carry US self-employment tax at 15.3% unless UK National Insurance cover is shown under the totalization agreement (opens the official SSA page in a new tab).

Does a teacher on PAYE need a UK Self Assessment return

Usually not, if the salary is the only income and the tax code is right, because PAYE collects the income tax at source. A return is needed if HMRC sends a notice to file, or if one of the triggers GOV.UK lists applies, such as self-employment, capital gains tax to pay, or a High Income Child Benefit Charge not collected through PAYE.

GOV.UK's page on who must send a tax return (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) also says you may need to file with foreign income or untaxed income. For an American, the common UK gap is interest on a US bank account, which is foreign income to a UK resident. The HMRC online checker (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) gives the answer for a given year. If a return is due, you register by 5 October after the tax year ends and file online by 31 January.

Filing with the IRS is not among the triggers GOV.UK lists. Where the US work turns up UK income never declared, our UK Self Assessment service handles that side.

  • Teaching salary only, correct tax code: usually no UK return
  • Private tutoring as a sole trader above the GOV.UK threshold: a return is due
  • Interest from a US bank account: check, as foreign income may need reporting
  • Child Benefit claimed with the charge not collected through PAYE: a return is due
  • A notice to file from HMRC: a return is due whatever the income

A worked example: a head of science in Cardiff

Take a US citizen who came to Cardiff to teach twelve years ago, now runs a secondary school science department, is married to a Welsh civil servant and has never filed a US return or FBAR. He is paid through PAYE and is an active member of the Teachers' Pension Scheme.

A colleague had told him the treaty's two-year teachers rule covered him; it does not, for both reasons above. He holds a Social Security number, and his passport and school calendars show well over 330 full days outside the US in each year, so the Foreign route is open.

His adviser rebuilt three calendar years of gross pay from payslips, including backdated arrears paid one January, and listed the UK tax deducted each month. With the foreign tax credit claimed, the salary produced no US tax. His pension contributions were tested against Article 18(5), and the position taken was disclosed. Interest on a cash ISA went into US income with no UK tax to credit against it, which left a small US balance, paid with interest.

His FBARs list his current account, joint savings with his wife, the ISA and a forgotten dollar account at a UK bank. His Form 14653 explains that PAYE had led him to believe his tax was settled. He needed no UK return. The full sequence is in our guide for people behind on US taxes in the UK.

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

Behind on US Taxes in the UK: IRS Streamlined Filing, Accidental Americans and Renunciation

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

I came to the UK on a teaching visa straight from the States. Did the two-year treaty exemption ever apply to me?

Not on your US return. The teachers article exempts pay only in the country being visited, here the UK, and the saving clause lets the US tax its citizens regardless. On the UK side the exemption covers teaching at a recognised educational institution and is lost retroactively once the stay passes two years, so a teacher who stayed on has no claim to it there either.

Will my teacher's pension be taxed twice when I retire in the UK?

Generally not twice in full. As a UK resident you are taxed on the pension by the UK, and the saving clause lets the US tax it as well because you are a citizen. The treaty's double tax relief article survives the saving clause, so UK tax paid on the pension is generally credited against the US tax on it. The government service pension article does not help a US citizen.

I tutor GCSE students privately in the evenings. Does that change my US or UK filing?

It can change both. In the US, net earnings from tutoring are self-employment income, which can attract self-employment tax at 15.3% unless you hold evidence of UK National Insurance cover under the totalization agreement. In the UK, a sole trader whose trading income passes the threshold GOV.UK sets must file a Self Assessment return. Keep a simple record of fees and costs for each year.

I have been teaching here for fifteen years. Do I have to file US returns for all of them?

Not under the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures. They ask for returns for the most recent three years whose due dates have passed and FBARs for the most recent six years, and leave earlier years alone. That is a feature of the procedure rather than a general IRS time limit, and it depends on qualifying: non-wilful conduct, the non-residency test, and no open IRS examination.

My school paid a backdated pay rise in January. Which US year does it go in?

Generally the year you received it. Individuals using the cash method count wages in the year they are paid or made available, so arrears paid in January belong to that new year even if they relate to the previous autumn. PAYE places them in the UK tax year in which they are paid, which may differ again, so build each US year from payslips rather than P60s.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us