Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

Catch-upBy US UK Tax Returns19 Nov 20267 min read

Missing PFIC forms: Form 8621 in a Streamlined catch-up

Stacks of fund statements and archive boxes on a home desk, gathered for Streamlined Form 8621 work

Several years of fund statements are the raw material for each missing Form 8621, so they are worth gathering before the catch-up starts.

A streamlined Form 8621 catch-up means one form for every PFIC you held in each of the three years of returns in the package, unless a small-holding exception excuses it for that year. Where no election was ever made, each fund sits in the default excess distribution regime. The awkward part is that a sale or a large distribution inside the window is taxed by reference to the whole time the shares were held, which usually began long before the window opened.

This post is for US citizens and green card holders in the UK who are preparing a Streamlined submission and own funds in a stocks and shares ISA or a general investment account without ever having filed Form 8621. Our guide for people behind on US taxes in the UK covers the procedure as a whole. Here we look at which years need the form, how the default regime works, why records from before the window still matter, what can and cannot be done about elections, and the assessment period trap.

Which years need Form 8621 in a Streamlined package

The covered tax years. The Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) ask for returns for the most recent three years whose due date has passed, each with the information returns that year requires. Form 8621 is one of them for every covered year in which you held shares in a passive foreign investment company.

The Form 8621 instructions (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) require a separate form for each PFIC held directly or indirectly, attached to the income tax return. An ISA holding four funds therefore produces four forms a year, and twelve across the window, before the general account is counted. The IRS page names Forms 3520, 5471 and 8938 as examples of information returns, but the list is illustrative, and Form 8621 belongs in the package wherever the instructions call for it.

The instructions also contain a small-holding exception. A shareholder whose PFIC stock is worth no more than $25,000 in total on the last day of the year, or $50,000 on a joint return, and who had no excess distribution or gain from the fund, may not need to report it. The test runs year by year, so a portfolio that crossed the line in the latest year needs forms for that year even if earlier years fell below it.

What happens to a UK fund when no election was made

It is a section 1291 fund, taxed under the default excess distribution regime. Ordinary distributions are included in income in the year received, but larger distributions and every gain on sale are spread across the time the shares were held, and the share falling in earlier PFIC years is taxed at that year's top rate with interest.

An excess distribution is the part of a year's distributions that exceeds a set multiple of the average received over the three preceding years, and none arises in the first year the shares are held. The instructions treat the whole of any gain on disposal as an excess distribution. Selling a fund, or switching from one fund to another inside an ISA, therefore produces US tax computed this way even though the UK charges nothing on it.

The computation works share by share. Each excess amount is allocated to every day in the holding period. Days in the current year, and days before the company was a PFIC, are taxed as ordinary income in the current year. Each earlier PFIC year bears an increase in tax at the highest individual rate in force for that year, with interest running from that year's return due date. UK tax on the same income can reduce the increase, but inside an ISA there is usually none to use.

How do years before the Streamlined window affect the calculation

They supply the numbers. The Streamlined pages do not ask for Forms 8621 for earlier years, yet an excess distribution or sale inside the window is spread across the whole holding period, so purchase dates, costs and distributions from those earlier years decide how much tax and interest the covered years carry.

Take a fund bought steadily over a decade and sold in the latest covered year. Most of the days in each lot's holding period fall before the window, so most of the gain is allocated to prior PFIC years, each taxed at its own top rate with interest from its own due date. The oldest purchases carry the longest interest periods. A computation that starts the clock at the beginning of the window understates both the tax and the interest.

The excess distribution test reaches back too. It compares a year's distributions with the average of the three years before, so for the first covered year the comparison years sit outside the window altogether. The instructions also say records relating to the form must be kept for as long as they may become material, and for a fund held under the default regime that can mean the life of the holding.

  • Contract notes or platform transaction histories showing each purchase date and price
  • Distribution records for at least the three years before the window opened
  • Records of fund switches and any transfer between providers made by selling to cash
  • Year-end values for each covered year, for Part I and the small-holding test
  • Copies of any Form 8621 filed in the past, with its attachments

Can a missed QEF or mark-to-market election be fixed in the catch-up

Not by filing a late form as though the election had been made on time. A QEF election is due by the return's due date, including extensions. A retroactive election is possible only under a protective statement already in place or with IRS consent under a regulation procedure, and the Streamlined pages offer no separate route.

The consent procedure has conditions of its own. The instructions say the request must be made before PFIC status is raised on audit and that the government's interests must not be prejudiced by granting it. A QEF election also depends on a PFIC Annual Information Statement from the fund for each year, showing the shareholder's share of ordinary earnings and net capital gain or enough to compute it. A UK tax voucher is written for HMRC and is not that statement unless it contains what the instructions require.

A mark-to-market election is made by the due date, including extensions, of the return for the year it first applies. Made after the first year of holding, it treats the shares as sold at their year-end value and taxes that gain as an excess distribution under the default rules, so it brings the history to tax rather than erasing it. Our post on QEF or mark-to-market elections for UK funds compares the two for later years.

Why does a missing Form 8621 matter if it carries no penalty

Because of the assessment period. Form 8621 has no standalone monetary penalty, but when a required information return is missing, the time the IRS has to assess tax for that year does not end until three years after the information is supplied. A missing form can therefore keep the whole return open.

The Internal Revenue Manual on international penalties (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) describes the extension under section 6501(c)(8): it covers items related to the missing information and can reach unrelated items, subject to a reasonable cause exception for those. Filing complete forms for the covered years starts the clock for them. On the Foreign route the IRS does not charge information return penalties for the covered years, though penalties already assessed stay in place.

The Streamlined Domestic Offshore Procedures (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) work differently and charge a 5% miscellaneous offshore penalty on the relevant foreign assets. On either route, years before the window in which a form was required but never filed lie outside what the Streamlined filing compliance procedures (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) ask for. Whether anything should be done about them depends on the facts of each case.

  • Assuming ISA funds escape US reporting because the UK does not tax them
  • Filing one Form 8621 for the whole ISA rather than one per fund
  • Applying the small-holding exception to a year with a sale or switch
  • Measuring gains and interest only from the start of the window
  • Treating a UK tax voucher as a PFIC Annual Information Statement

What might a Leeds ISA holder's Form 8621 catch-up look like

Take a US citizen working as a solicitor in Leeds who opened a stocks and shares ISA (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) about ten years ago and a general investment account later. She has bought index funds in both most years, switched one ISA fund in the latest covered year, and never filed a US return or an FBAR.

Her adviser first lists every holding and checks each for PFIC status. Collective funds domiciled outside the US, including UK unit trusts and OEICs, are commonly PFICs, as our post on why a stocks and shares ISA worries the IRS explains, while the investment trusts in her general account are reviewed separately using our post on whether UK investment trusts are PFICs. Her year-end totals sit above the small-holding line in every covered year, so each fund needs a Form 8621 for each year.

The switch is a disposal. Its gain is allocated across each lot's holding period back to her first subscription, so contract notes from the early years decide most of the tax and interest. Funds still held produce Part I reporting and no excess distribution. Our IRS streamlined filing service assembles the returns, six years of FBARs and Form 14653, the PFIC reporting service prepares the computations, and individual tax returns work keeps later years current. The wider procedure is set out in our guide for people behind on US taxes in the UK.

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

Behind on US Taxes in the UK: IRS Streamlined Filing, Accidental Americans and Renunciation

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

Do I file Form 8621 for years before the three Streamlined years?

The Streamlined procedures ask for returns, with their information returns, for the three covered years only, so earlier Forms 8621 are not part of the standard package. The history from those years still matters, because a sale or large distribution inside the window is spread across the whole holding period. Whether anything further is needed for older years is a judgement on the facts.

My ISA funds were small. Can I leave Form 8621 out?

Possibly, for some years. The instructions excuse reporting where all PFIC stock is worth no more than $25,000 at the end of the year, or $50,000 on a joint return, and there was no excess distribution or gain. A sale or switch in the year takes the fund outside that relief, and the value is tested afresh each year.

Will the IRS waive penalties for my missing PFIC forms?

On the Foreign route, a complete submission is not subject to information return penalties for the covered years, though tax and interest on the PFIC computations are still due. The Domestic route charges a 5% miscellaneous offshore penalty instead. Form 8621 has no standalone penalty anyway; the real cost of leaving it out is a return that stays open to assessment.

I switched funds inside my ISA. Is that a sale for US purposes?

Generally yes. Swapping one fund for another means disposing of the first, and under the default regime the whole gain on a disposal is treated as an excess distribution. It is spread over the days you held those shares, with the earlier years taxed at their top rates plus interest. The UK ignores the switch because it happened inside the ISA wrapper.

My platform only shows recent statements. How do I find old purchase prices?

Ask the platform, and any provider you transferred from, for a full transaction history and contract notes back to the first purchase. Bank statements showing subscriptions help fix dates. Where a record cannot be found, keep a written note of how each figure was reconstructed and what it rests on, because the computation and its support may need to be explained later.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us