When a British retiree becomes resident in the United States, a UK pension is taxed in the US treaty way for most income: workplace and personal pensions and the UK State Pension go to the US alone under Article 17 of the US-UK income tax treaty (opens the official IRS page in a new tab). Government service pensions are the exception. Under Article 19 the UK keeps them until you become a US citizen, and a green card on its own does not stop the US taxing them as well. Lump sums remain the unsettled point.
This post is for British nationals who retire to America and keep drawing pensions from home. Our guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation mostly looks out from Britain; this post looks back from America. It takes each pension in turn, sets out how HMRC is asked to stop deducting tax, and explains why naturalisation matters.
Which country taxes a UK private pension after you move to the US
The United States, alone. Article 17(1)(a) gives pensions and similar remuneration beneficially owned by a resident of one country to that country only. Once you are resident in the US for treaty purposes, income from a UK workplace pension, a personal pension or drawdown is taxed on your US return, and the UK loses its right to tax it.
Residence here means treaty residence under Article 4. A green card holder is resident for US tax purposes from the first day present as a lawful permanent resident, as the IRS page on the green card test (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) explains, and Publication 519 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) says resident aliens are generally taxed on worldwide income, the same as citizens. In the year of the move, our post on the treaty tie-breaker shows how Article 4 picks one country.
Article 17(1)(b) adds a protection that survives the saving clause for everyone: any part of a UK scheme payment that would be exempt from UK tax for a UK resident is exempt in the US too. The Treasury's technical explanation (opens the official US Treasury page in a new tab) illustrates it with a Roth IRA paid to a UK resident. The taxable part follows the annuity rules in Publication 575 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab).
- Workplace or personal pension income. Article 17(1)(a): taxed only in the US once you live there
- Purchased annuity, or the UK State Pension. Articles 17(4) and 17(3): US only
- Lump sum from a UK scheme. Article 17(2): left to the UK, with an open US question
- Civil service, armed forces, police and state-school teachers. Article 19(2): turns on citizenship
What happens to a UK pension lump sum once you live in the US
Article 17(2) sends a lump sum from a UK scheme, received by a US resident, back to the UK alone. The difficulty lies on the US side. The saving clause in Article 1(4) lets the US tax its residents, not only its citizens, as if the treaty had not come into effect, and paragraph 2 of Article 17 is not among its exceptions.
So a British retiree holding a green card meets the same uncertainty that our post on whether a UK pension lump sum is taxable in the US describes for citizens. The case for exemption runs through Article 17(1)(b), which is protected; the case against reads paragraph 2 as displacing paragraph 1 for lump sums. Because the answer is unsettled, when the lump sum is paid relative to the start of US residence deserves attention before the move, alongside the UK rules on what is tax-free (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab).
On the UK side, the treaty leaves lump sums with the UK. HMRC's notes to its claim form cover one case: tax deducted from a trivial commutation payment can be repaid if you were US resident on the day it was paid.
Who taxes the UK State Pension when you retire to America
Only the United States. Article 17(3) says payments under one country's social security legislation to a resident of the other country are taxable only in that other country. A UK State Pension paid to someone living in the US is precisely that case, whatever passport the pensioner holds, and the paragraph is protected from the saving clause.
The paragraph only works across the border: the paying country and the country of residence must differ. That is why a US citizen living in Britain pays UK tax on the same pension, as our post on the UK State Pension on a US tax return explains, and why US benefits paid to someone in Britain go to the UK alone, covered in US Social Security for UK residents. GOV.UK also lists the USA among the countries where the annual increase (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) is paid, so the pension does not freeze.
Are civil service, police and teachers' pensions taxed differently
Yes. Article 19(2) overrides Article 17 for pensions paid by, or out of funds created by, the UK government or a local authority for services rendered to it. Such a pension is taxable only in the UK, unless the pensioner is both resident in and a national of the United States, in which case only the US may tax it.
Which pensions count is settled by HMRC's classification in its International Manual. Civil service, armed forces, police, fire service, local authority and state-school teachers' pensions are government pensions. NHS pensions paid by the NHS Business Services Authority are listed as non-government, so they fall under Article 17(1); an NHS pension paid by a local authority is the exception. Private-school teachers' pensions are non-government too, and Article 19(3) sends pensions from a government-run business back to Article 17.
On the US side, immigration status decides, because the saving clause applies. Article 1(5)(b) keeps the Article 19 exemption only for people who are neither US citizens nor admitted for permanent residence. A retiree living in the US without a green card keeps it. A green card holder does not: the UK taxes the pension, the US taxes it as worldwide income, and Article 24 requires a US credit for the UK tax.
Naturalisation reverses the order. A British national who becomes a US citizen while living in America is then resident in and a national of the US, so Article 19(2)(b) gives the pension to the US alone. Keeping British citizenship makes no difference to that paragraph.
- British national living in the US without a green card. UK taxes; US exempts under Article 19, kept by Article 1(5)(b)
- British national holding a green card. UK taxes; US also taxes and credits the UK tax
- British national who has naturalised as a US citizen. US taxes alone under Article 19(2)(b); UK exempts on a claim
- NHS pension paid by the NHS Business Services Authority. Not a government pension; US alone under Article 17(1)
How do you stop HMRC deducting tax from a UK pension
By sending HMRC form US-Individual 2002, its claim form under the US treaty, certified by the IRS. It asks HMRC to grant relief at source on future payments and to repay tax already taken. US residents use this country form rather than HMRC's general DT-Individual form, which serves countries without a form of their own.
The GOV.UK page for form US-Individual 2002 (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) says it covers pensions, purchased annuities, incapacity benefit, interest and royalties paid to US residents. HMRC's notes make relief conditional on the IRS confirming US residence, so the form goes to the IRS with Form 8802 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab), the application for residency certification, and its user fee. Where HMRC cannot arrange relief at source, the tax is repaid instead.
Once a claim is accepted, HMRC can tell the payer to stop deducting tax; its PAYE manual lists treaty exemptions among the uses of code NT, meaning no tax on that income. For a PAYE pension, the adjustment runs back to the latest of when you became US resident, when payments began, and the earliest tax year still open for repayment. Government pension claims are checked against Article 19, not accepted automatically.
- List every UK source. HMRC's manual says each new source of income needs its own claim
- Use the right part. State Pension in part C.1; workplace and personal pensions in part C.2
- Attach the latest P60. HMRC asks for it to make the PAYE adjustment
- Send it through the IRS with Form 8802. The IRS certifies your US residence to HMRC
- Report changes promptly. Naturalisation can bring a government pension into the claim
What changes on the US return when you become a US citizen
Less than people expect for most pensions. A green card holder is already taxed on worldwide income and already within the saving clause, so citizenship adds little for private pensions or the State Pension. Its main effect is on Article 19, where it moves a government pension to the US and removes the UK tax that was being credited.
Article 1(5)(a) protects Article 17(1)(b), Article 17(3) and Article 24 for citizens and residents alike; our post on the saving clause gives the full list. UK tax properly deducted, as on a government pension while you hold a green card, is credited on Form 1116. Publication 514 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) allows credit only for the legal and actual foreign liability, so UK tax taken from a private pension before HMRC accepts your claim is reclaimed from HMRC instead.
Unused credit in a category carries back one year and forward ten years. On disclosure, the Form 8833 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) instructions waive reporting where a treaty reduces or modifies the tax on pensions, annuities, social security and other public pensions, so an Article 19 exemption claimed by a retiree without a green card is usually not reportable. A contested lump sum position is a different matter, and our post on Form 8833 for UK treaty positions explains when the cautious course is to file it anyway.
How this works for a retired teacher moving to Arizona
Take a retired deputy head from Leeds who moves to Arizona on a green card. She draws a Teachers' Pension from state-school service, income from a personal pension, and the UK State Pension. She is a British national only, and the tie-breaker treats her as resident in the US from the move.
Her personal pension and State Pension go to the US alone under Articles 17(1) and 17(3). She files form US-Individual 2002 with Form 8802, listing both and attaching her latest P60, so UK deductions stop. Both appear on her Form 1040, prepared through our individual tax returns service.
The Teachers' Pension is different. As a government pension it stays taxable in the UK under Article 19(2)(a), and because she holds a green card the US taxes it as well, with a credit for the UK tax, under the article our US-UK tax treaty summary sets out. When she later naturalises, Article 19(2)(b) gives it to the US alone; a fresh claim to HMRC ends the UK tax and the matching credit.
Our US-UK pensions service and treaty relief team review these positions yearly, and the guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation places them among the other reliefs.
General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.



