Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

Catch-upBy US UK Tax Returns3 Nov 20268 min read

Behind on US taxes as a council employee in the UK: what the catch-up involves

Council worker in a hi-vis vest holds a tablet on a high street near the town hall, a US citizen council employee with UK taxes

Council pay arrives with pension contributions and salary sacrifice already taken off, which is the first thing to unpick when rebuilding the US returns.

Anyone looking into US citizen council employee UK taxes is usually holding a P60 and hoping it settles everything. It settles HMRC only. A US citizen or green card holder on a council payroll owes the IRS a return for each year income passes the filing threshold, plus FBARs, and the treaty's government service article does not change that. Someone who has never filed usually comes back through the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures (opens the official IRS page in a new tab): returns for three years, FBARs for six years, a signed certification and any tax and interest due.

This post is for social workers, planners, librarians, administrators and other staff of county, district, borough and unitary councils who have never filed. It sits beneath our guide for people behind on US taxes in the UK. The treaty points shared with Whitehall staff are in our post on civil servants catching up, so here we deal with what a council payslip adds: LGPS deductions, salary sacrifice, car allowances, professional fees and the steps in order.

Does the treaty treat council pay as government service

Yes, but that gives a US citizen no protection. Article 19(1) of the treaty covers pay from the public funds of a political subdivision or local authority, so a council salary sits inside the government service article. The saving clause then lets the US tax its own citizens and green card holders as though the article did not exist.

The wording of the US-UK treaty (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) is precise. Article 1(4) allows each country to tax its citizens as if the convention had not come into effect, except as paragraph 5 provides. Article 1(5)(b) keeps Article 19 only for individuals who are neither citizens of the country nor admitted to it for permanent residence. A council officer with a US passport or a green card is therefore taxed by the US on the whole salary, and avoids paying twice through the foreign tax credit, because Article 1(5)(a) preserves Article 24 for everyone.

Article 19(3) sends pay for work in a business carried on by a local authority back to the ordinary employment article, but for a citizen the result does not move. Our explainer on the treaty saving clause covers the wider analysis.

Which council payslip figures go on the US return

Gross pay for the calendar year, before LGPS contributions and before any salary sacrifice, converted into dollars and reported as wages on Form 1040. The taxable pay on a P60 is the wrong starting point, because it runs from 6 April to 5 April and has already had pension contributions and sacrificed pay taken out.

HMRC's page on tax relief for pension contributions (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) explains that where an employer takes workplace pension contributions out of pay before deducting income tax, relief arrives through payroll. The Local Government Pension Scheme works that way: the member site run by the Local Government Association says contributions attract tax relief when deducted from pay, at a rate the employer sets each April from the member's pensionable pay. The US does not follow that relief automatically. Whether LGPS contributions can be left out of US income turns on Article 18(5) and its conditions, which our post on UK pension contributions under Article 18 works through.

Council pay is not US government pay, so it is foreign earned income: the Form 2555 instructions (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) exclude only amounts paid by the US Government or its agencies to their employees. Both the exclusion and the credit are therefore open. For a salary fully taxed through PAYE (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab), the credit on Form 1116 usually leaves no US tax on pay, and unused credit can be carried back one year and forward ten. Our post on the credit or the exclusion in the UK sets out the trade-off.

  • Basic salary and any back pay, placed in the calendar year it was actually paid
  • Overtime, standby, call-out payments and honoraria for acting up
  • LGPS member contributions, kept separate so the treaty position can be applied
  • Each salary sacrifice deduction, with a note of the benefit it buys
  • Car allowances and mileage claims, split into lump sum and per-mile payments

How does a council salary sacrifice scheme affect US income

Usually it shrinks the UK figure more than the US one. Salary sacrifice swaps cash pay for a benefit, and HMRC then taxes that benefit on its own terms. The IRS starts from a different rule: a benefit received for your work is income unless a US provision specifically excludes it.

HMRC's guidance on salary sacrifice and PAYE describes it as an agreement to reduce an employee's entitlement to cash pay, usually in return for a non-cash benefit. For newer arrangements the benefit is generally valued at the higher of the salary given up and the normal benefit charge, with a short list of exceptions that includes pension contributions and bicycles under cycle to work schemes. A council may also offer shared cost additional voluntary contributions by sacrifice, which the LGPS member site says carry no tax or National Insurance.

Publication 525 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) says fringe benefits received in connection with your services are included in income as compensation unless you pay fair market value for them or they are specifically excluded by law. A sacrifice HMRC ignores can therefore still leave something to report. A bicycle or car provided under a council scheme is valued under the US rules, while extra pension bought by sacrifice needs to be considered alongside the LGPS treaty analysis rather than on its own.

How are essential car user allowances and council mileage treated

In two parts. Councils paying on National Joint Council terms give essential users a lump sum plus a rate per mile, and casual users a mileage rate only. The per-mile payments are compared with the IRS business rate, as for any employer. The essential user lump sum is the harder piece.

HMRC's Employment Income Manual says local authority staff paid under the NJC arrangements fall under the ordinary approved mileage allowance rules, with no special tax arrangement. Its National Insurance Manual accepts most local authority lump sums as a reasonable estimate of business car costs, charging Class 1 only on any profit element.

The US looks at it another way. Our post on mileage allowances on a US return explains the per-mile comparison and the logs it needs. Publication 463 recognises an allowance combining a fixed amount and a rate per mile only under its fixed and variable rate method, which the employer must choose to operate. A council paying on NJC terms is unlikely to have set its lump sum up on that basis, so the prudent starting point is to treat it as wages on the US return unless a review of the scheme supports a different answer.

Can a council worker deduct registration and union fees in the US

Not for the years a current catch-up covers. HMRC gives relief for professional fees you must pay to do your job and for subscriptions to bodies on its approved list, but the IRS allows no deduction for unreimbursed employee expenses. The UK relief still matters, because it changes the UK tax figure used in the credit.

GOV.UK's page on professional fees and subscriptions allows a claim for membership fees you must pay to do your job, and for annual subscriptions to approved professional bodies or learned societies relevant to the work. Fees your employer paid do not count, and anyone in Self Assessment claims through that return. The annual registration a social worker must hold to practise is the kind of cost the rule is aimed at; a union subscription qualifies only if the union appears on HMRC's list.

On the US side, Publication 529 says miscellaneous itemised deductions subject to the old floor based on adjusted gross income can no longer be claimed, and names unreimbursed employee expenses among them. So these fees reduce UK tax only. Where a late UK claim produces a refund, the UK tax for that year falls, and Publication 514 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) treats a refund of foreign tax as a foreign tax redetermination that can require notice to the IRS. Making the HMRC claim before the US returns are prepared avoids that step.

What are the catch-up steps for US citizen council employee UK taxes

Six steps, taken in order. The Streamlined procedures (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) require non-wilful conduct, a valid taxpayer identification number and no open IRS examination. The Foreign route also needs no US abode and 330 full days outside the United States in at least one of the last three years whose due dates have passed.

Pay is converted by one consistent method, usually the IRS yearly average rate (opens the official IRS page in a new tab). Each year's FBAR (opens the official FinCEN page in a new tab) is filed electronically with FinCEN, separately from the returns, when the combined highest balances of your foreign accounts passed $10,000. Signature authority counts, which can catch an officer who signs on a union branch account. Each year goes on FinCEN Form 114.

On the Foreign route, compliant non-wilful filers face no failure-to-file, failure-to-pay, accuracy-related, information return or FBAR penalties. An LGPS treaty position is disclosed on Form 8833. Our post on proving the non-residency test covers the evidence for the day count.

  • Step 1: confirm US citizenship or green card status and find, or apply for, a Social Security number
  • Step 2: check for IRS letters and count days outside the US for each recent year
  • Step 3: rebuild three years of calendar-year gross pay, before pension and sacrifice deductions
  • Step 4: schedule each salary sacrifice, car allowance and fee claim with its documents
  • Step 5: list every account owned or signed on across six years, with each year's highest balance
  • Step 6: prepare the returns, Form 1116, any treaty disclosure and Form 14653, then post, file the FBARs and pay

What might a council social worker's catch-up look like

Take a children's social worker employed by a county council in the East Midlands, born in Texas to a British father and schooled in England. She is an essential car user, bought a bicycle through the council's cycle scheme, pays LGPS contributions, claims relief on her registration fee and has never filed a US return or FBAR.

Her adviser rebuilt three calendar years from gross pay on her payslips. The essential user lump sum went in as wages, and the per-mile payments were compared with the IRS business rate for each journey date. The bicycle was valued under the US rules. Her LGPS contributions were tested against Article 18(5) and the position disclosed. With UK tax credited, the salary produced no US tax, and her Form 14653 followed the structure in our post on writing the non-wilful certification.

Her six FBARs list a current account, a savings account and a cash ISA. Our IRS streamlined filing service prepares packages like hers around Form 1040, our US-UK pensions service reviews LGPS positions, and our individual tax returns work keeps later years current. Her council pension, once paid, is covered by our post on teachers', council and police pensions, and the full sequence is in our guide for people behind on US taxes in the UK.

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

Behind on US Taxes in the UK: IRS Streamlined Filing, Accidental Americans and Renunciation

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

I work part-time for the council and earn less than the UK personal allowance. Do I still need to file?

Possibly. The UK personal allowance has no bearing on the US duty. A US return is due when gross income passes the US filing threshold for your filing status, and for married filing separately, the usual status for someone married to a non-US spouse, that threshold is only $5. Single filers have a higher threshold, so check the figure for each year being filed.

Will my LGPS pension be exempt from US tax when I start drawing it?

Not if you are still a US citizen or green card holder. Article 19(2) gives a pension for service to a local authority to the UK alone, but the saving clause removes that protection for US citizens and green card holders. The pension goes on the US return when paid, and the UK tax deducted under PAYE is credited. Growth inside the scheme before then is generally protected under Article 18(1).

I am employed by a company the council owns, not the council itself. Is my position different?

For US purposes, rarely. The company is a separate employer, and whether its pay counts as paid by the authority under Article 19 depends on the facts. Article 19(3) also sends pay for work in a business carried on by an authority back to the ordinary employment article. For a US citizen the result is the same either way: foreign wages on the US return, with UK tax credited.

Should my council give me a Form W-2 for the US return?

No. A Form W-2 is a statement issued by US employers. A UK council reports your pay to HMRC through PAYE and gives you payslips and a P60, which cover the UK tax year. The US figures are built from the monthly payslips for each calendar year, converted into dollars, with the UK tax shown on them supporting the foreign tax credit claim.

I only joined the council last year. Do my earlier jobs still matter?

Yes. The Streamlined returns cover the most recent three years whose due dates have passed, and each return reports worldwide income for the whole calendar year, whoever paid it. Pay from a previous employer, in the UK or elsewhere, goes in alongside the council salary. The six FBAR years also include accounts you have since closed, so older bank statements are worth gathering early.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us