Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

ReturnsBy US UK Tax Returns16 Nov 20267 min read

Payrolling benefits in kind 2027: what changes for Americans on a UK payroll

Employee collects company car keys in an office car park, ahead of payrolling benefits in kind 2027

Once benefits such as a company car run through payroll in 2027, the P60 alone no longer shows a US preparer which pay is a benefit.

Payrolling benefits in kind becomes compulsory in 2027 for the most common benefits. From 6 April 2027, UK employers must tax company cars, car fuel, vans, van fuel and medical insurance through payroll each pay period instead of reporting them on a P11D after the year ends, according to HMRC's guidance on preparing for mandatory payrolling (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab). Most other benefits follow from April 2028, while loans and accommodation stay outside. The UK tax due does not change, but the papers behind your US return do.

This post is for US citizens and green card holders employed in Britain who receive benefits from their employer. It adds payroll detail that our guide to US and UK tax returns for Americans in the UK leaves out. It covers what moves into payroll and when, how payslips and the P60 change, why the UK benefit figure is not automatically the US one, the exception for globally mobile employees, and the calendar-year and foreign tax credit points.

What changes with payrolling benefits in kind in 2027

The reporting route changes, not the tax. From 6 April 2027 employers must deduct income tax and Class 1A National Insurance on company cars and fuel, vans and fuel, and medical insurance in real time through payroll. From 6 April 2028 the rule reaches all other benefits except employment-related loans and accommodation.

Until now most employers have reported benefits once a year on form P11D, and HMRC has adjusted the employee's tax code to collect the tax. Under payrolling the cash equivalent of each benefit is added to taxable pay in each pay period and taxed there, and HMRC says payrolled benefits no longer need a P11D or P11D(b). The existing rules on valuation, making good and exemptions still apply, so the amount taxed in the UK should match what the P11D would have shown.

Employers can also payroll other benefits voluntarily by registering before the tax year in which they want to start, and many already do. HMRC's policy paper on real-time reporting from April 2027 (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) says excluded benefits such as loans and accommodation continue under year-end reporting for now. In 2027/28 an employee can therefore have some benefits inside the payslip and others on a P11D, and the US return needs both.

  • From 6 April 2027: company cars, car fuel, vans, van fuel and medical insurance
  • From 6 April 2028: most remaining benefits in kind
  • Outside the mandate: employment-related loans and living accommodation
  • Benefits given as part of a termination payment: no need to payroll them
  • Payrolled benefits: no P11D or P11D(b) required for them

How payrolled benefits appear on your payslip and P60

The benefit value joins your taxable pay. HMRC's payrolling guidance (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) tells employers to include the taxable amount in the P60 figure for total taxable pay in the year, and tax codes will no longer carry an adjustment for payrolled benefits. After the year ends, your employer must tell you in writing what was payrolled.

That notice is due by 1 June after the tax year and can come as a payslip, an email or a letter. It must list the benefits payrolled and their values, and any benefits not payrolled, and in the first year it must explain the change to your tax code. Keep it with the P60, because it is the one document that separates benefits from cash salary inside the P60 total. Our post on mileage allowance on your US return shows the same issue with expenses that run through payroll.

The changeover can blur the picture for a while. HMRC's policy paper says that during the first two years some people will pay tax on current-year benefits through payroll while still paying amounts for earlier years through their tax code. That earlier-year tax belongs to an earlier UK tax year, which matters for the US foreign tax credit discussed below. HMRC's guidance says employees will not pay more tax overall because of the change.

Why the UK benefit figure is not always the US figure

Each country values benefits by its own rules. HMRC uses a statutory cash equivalent, such as the list price and emissions basis for a company car. The US includes a fringe benefit at fair market value unless the law excludes it, and some benefits HMRC taxes are excluded from US income altogether.

Medical insurance is the clearest case. Publication 525 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) says that in most cases the value of accident or health plan coverage provided by your employer is not included in your income. Private medical cover from a UK employer is a taxable benefit in the UK, so once it is payrolled it sits inside P60 taxable pay. A preparer who copies the P60 total onto the US return may include an amount the US generally leaves out. Our post on company-paid private medical cover looks at that benefit in more depth.

Cars follow a different logic again. Publication 525 values an employer-provided car under a general rule based on what it would cost to lease a comparable vehicle, and says the special valuation rules can generally be used only if your employer uses them, which a UK employer running UK payroll is unlikely to do. Business use is generally excluded as a working condition benefit, so the US amount turns on personal use. Publication 15-B (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) sets out the same rules from the employer's side.

Does the globally mobile employee exception apply to you

It may, if your work crosses borders. HMRC lets employers apply for an exception for globally mobile employees, who then stay on year-end P11D reporting. The employer applies, not the employee, HMRC asks for applications by 5 April 2027 for the first year, and an exception cannot be backdated.

HMRC's page on the globally mobile employee exception (opens the official GOV.UK page in a new tab) sets two conditions besides being globally mobile: the employee is likely to receive benefits or expenses in at least two pay periods in a tax year, and the employer will not have enough information to payroll them when they are received. Short business trips, occasional overseas meetings, remote working abroad and other temporary travel usually do not qualify. The exception changes only how and when benefits are reported, not the tax or National Insurance due.

An American seconded from a US parent company and expected to work in both countries is the kind of employee who may fall within it. If the exception applies, all of that employee's benefits stay on the P11D, because an employer cannot payroll some and report others. An exception can only end on 5 April, at the close of a tax year. Ask your payroll team which route applies before 2027/28 begins, since the answer decides which document your US preparer works from.

What payrolling means for the calendar-year US return

It can make the US return easier. A P11D gives one annual figure for a UK tax year that straddles two US tax years. Payrolled benefits arrive pay period by pay period, so the amounts for January to December can be read from payslips and converted at the same rates you use for salary.

The US return covers the calendar year, while the UK tax year runs from 6 April to 5 April. With a P11D, preparers apportioned the annual benefit across two US years, usually by time. Payroll records give actual monthly amounts instead. Publication 54 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) treats amounts an employer pays to a third party on your behalf as employer-provided income, so taxable benefits generally form part of foreign earned income if you claim the exclusion on Form 2555, although for most UK employees the foreign tax credit gives the better result.

The credit follows the tax. UK tax on a payrolled benefit is deducted in the same pay period as the benefit, which lines up income and credit on Form 1116. Earlier-year tax collected through a tax code during the changeover relates to an earlier UK year, so it belongs with that year's income under the timing method you use, which our post on paid or accrued foreign tax explains. Class 1A is an employer contribution, not your tax.

  • Read payrolled benefit amounts from each payslip in the calendar year
  • Set aside benefits the US generally excludes, such as medical cover
  • Value a company car for the US on personal use, not HMRC's cash equivalent
  • Match UK tax on each benefit to the US year it relates to
  • Keep the employer's year-end benefits notice with the P60

Which steps to take before 6 April 2027

Find out which of your benefits will be payrolled, whether you fall within the globally mobile exception, and what year-end notice to expect. Then agree with your US preparer how payroll figures will be split between excluded benefits and taxable pay before the first payslip of 2027/28 arrives.

Take a US citizen working as a sales director for a UK engineering company in Bristol. She has a company car with fuel for private journeys and family private medical cover, and her employer will payroll both from April 2027. Her US return for 2027 will cover three months under the P11D system and nine under payrolling, so a single year holds both kinds of record.

Her preparer takes the January to March benefits from a time-apportioned share of the 2026/27 P11D and the April to December amounts from her payslips. The medical cover is set aside as generally excluded under US rules, and the car is valued for the US on her personal use. UK tax is matched to each part of the year on Form 1116. Our payroll services and individual tax returns teams cover both sides, and the wider routine is in our guide for Americans in the UK.

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

US and UK Tax Returns for Americans in the UK

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

Will I pay more tax once my company car goes through payroll?

Not according to HMRC. Its guidance tells employers to explain that employees will not pay more tax overall because of the change, and the existing valuation and exemption rules still apply. What changes is timing: tax is collected each pay period instead of through a tax code adjustment. In the first years some people also pay earlier-year amounts through their code, so take-home pay can dip for a while.

My employer already payrolls my benefits voluntarily. Does anything change for me?

Less than for most employees. Voluntary payrolling already puts benefits into taxable pay and the P60 total. HMRC's guidance says that from April 2027 employers must also deal with Class 1A National Insurance in real time for payrolled benefits, which is an employer cost. For your US return the points are unchanged: keep the year-end benefits notice and separate anything the US treats differently.

Will I still get a P11D for my interest-free loan from work?

Probably, unless your employer chooses to payroll it. Loans and living accommodation sit outside both phases of mandatory payrolling, and HMRC's policy paper says excluded benefits continue under year-end arrangements for now. Employers can payroll them voluntarily by registering before the tax year starts. Ask your payroll team, because the document your US preparer needs depends on the answer.

Is UK private medical insurance taxable on my US return?

Generally not. Publication 525 says that in most cases the value of accident or health plan coverage your employer provides is not included in income. It remains a taxable benefit in the UK, so once payrolled it sits inside your P60 taxable pay. Ask your preparer how the UK tax on it is treated when the foreign tax credit is worked out, because that part needs looking at.

I am on secondment from the US. Who applies for the globally mobile exception?

Your UK employer does. HMRC asks employers to apply as soon as they know an employee is, or is likely to be, globally mobile, and by 5 April 2027 for the first year. The start date cannot be earlier than the application, so a late request leaves benefits on payroll until it takes effect. If the exception applies, all your benefits stay on the P11D.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us