On US citizen police officer UK taxes, the short answer is that PAYE settles the British side only. The United States still expects a return for each year your income passes the filing threshold, plus FBARs for your UK accounts. An officer who has never filed usually catches up through the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures (opens the official IRS page in a new tab), with returns for three years, FBARs for six years, a signed certification and any tax and interest, which on a fully taxed police salary is often small.
This post is for officers in a UK force who hold US citizenship or a green card and have filed nothing with the IRS. It extends our guide for people behind on US taxes in the UK with the points police service adds: overtime and rest day pay, the Police Pension Scheme and its commuted lump sum, why the treaty's government service article does not help, accounts you sign on for a club or branch fund, and what a green card changes.
Can a police officer use the Streamlined Foreign Offshore route
Usually, yes. A US citizen or green card holder qualifies if, in at least one of the last three years whose due dates have passed, they had no US abode and spent 330 full days outside the United States. The failures must be non-wilful, and no IRS civil examination or criminal investigation can be under way.
The test is on the IRS page for US taxpayers residing outside the United States (opens the official IRS page in a new tab). Long service in Britain usually passes it easily. Secondments, exchanges or courses in the United States are where it tightens. The Streamlined procedures (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) also require a valid Social Security number on every return, so an officer who never had one should apply before anything else.
Non-wilful means negligence, inadvertence, mistake or a good faith misunderstanding of the law, and you certify it on Form 14653 under penalty of perjury. Officers write statements for a living, and the same habits serve well here: first person, dated facts, nothing assumed. Our post on writing the non-wilful certification sets out a structure.
- Step 1: confirm your US status and locate or apply for a Social Security number
- Step 2: check for IRS contact and count days outside the US for each year
- Step 3: rebuild three calendar years of gross pay from monthly payslips
- Step 4: list every account you owned or signed on across six years
- Step 5: prepare the returns, FBARs and certification, then pay tax and interest
How are police overtime and allowances reported on a US return
As wages, in the calendar year they are paid. Overtime, pay for working rest days and public holidays, on-call payments and taxable allowances all belong in gross pay on Form 1040. Overtime claimed late in the year is often paid in a later month, so December's hours can fall into the next US year.
That timing is why the P60 is the wrong starting point. It covers 6 April to 5 April, while each US return covers January to December. Build every US year from monthly payslips, and convert the pounds by one consistent method, usually the IRS yearly average rate (opens the official IRS page in a new tab). Start from gross pay, before pension contributions, because the US relief for those contributions is a treaty question dealt with below.
The new US deduction for overtime will rarely help. IRS guidance limits it to the premium element of overtime that section 7 of the Fair Labor Standards Act requires, and says overtime paid under other rules, such as state law or a collective agreement, does not qualify. Police overtime in Britain is paid under UK police regulations, so it sits outside. Our post on no tax on overtime for Americans in the UK covers the detail.
- Basic pay for each calendar month
- Overtime and rest day working, in the month actually paid
- On-call, shift or location allowances shown as taxable pay
- Any payment shown as free of UK tax, which still needs a US answer
- Pension contributions and UK income tax deducted each month
Is the foreign tax credit or the exclusion better for police pay
For most officers, the foreign tax credit. Police pay is taxed in full through PAYE at UK rates that are generally higher than US rates on the same income, so crediting that tax usually removes the US tax on the salary and leaves unused credit to carry. The exclusion is available but seldom wins.
Publication 514 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) is plain that no credit or deduction is allowed for foreign tax on income you exclude, so excluding a salary wastes the UK tax paid on it. Unused credit can generally be carried back one year and forward ten. The credit is claimed on Form 1116, and the exclusion on Form 2555.
The credit is worked out separately for different kinds of income, so a balance can still appear on savings even when wages show nothing. ISA interest is the usual source, because the UK charges no tax on it to credit. The reasoning matches what we set out for NHS staff catching up, and our individual tax returns work runs both computations before a choice is made.
- Credit: UK tax on the salary offsets US tax on the same pay
- Exclusion: removes wages up to $130,000 for tax year 2025
- Exclusion: no credit for UK tax on the excluded pay
- Exclusion: revoking it bars a fresh election for five years without IRS approval
How is the Police Pension Scheme treated under the US-UK treaty
In three parts. Growth inside the scheme is generally not taxed by the US until benefits are paid, because Article 18(1) survives the saving clause. Relief for contributions and yearly accrual depends on Article 18(5) and its conditions. The pension in payment is taxable by both countries, with a US credit for UK tax.
Officers in England and Wales belong to the 1987 or 2006 legacy schemes or the 2015 career average scheme. All are defined benefit, and contributions come out of pay before income tax. Article 18(5) of the US-UK treaty (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) lets a US citizen resident here leave contributions and accrued benefits out of US income only so far as they get UK relief, only up to what a generally corresponding US plan would allow, and only if the US competent authority has agreed that the scheme corresponds. The Technical Explanation (opens the official US Treasury page in a new tab) links that agreement to retirement benefit schemes under the Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1988, so how a statutory police scheme fits is checked for each case.
Article 19(2) would normally give a government pension to the paying state alone, and Article 19(1) does the same for public pay. Article 1(5)(b) keeps both only for people who are neither US citizens nor admitted for permanent residence. What survives is Article 24 on relief from double taxation, so UK tax on the pension is generally credited against the US tax on it. Our post on the treaty saving clause explains the mechanism.
Commuting part of the pension for a lump sum is the contested point. The Technical Explanation says a US citizen living in the UK stays taxable in the US on a lump sum despite Article 17(2), while Article 17(1)(b), which survives the saving clause, limits US tax on pension payments to the part the UK would tax. Our post on whether a UK pension lump sum is taxable in the US weighs the readings. Any treaty position goes on Form 8833, and our US-UK pensions service reviews it before you retire.
Which accounts belong on a police officer's FBARs
Every foreign financial account you own or can sign on, in any year when their combined highest values passed $10,000. That covers current, savings and ISA accounts, a credit union account, and accounts you sign on for others, such as a sports club, branch or charity fund where you act as treasurer.
The FBAR (opens the official FinCEN page in a new tab) is filed electronically with FinCEN, not with the tax return, and falls due on 15 April, extended automatically to 15 October. Each account's highest balance in the year is converted using the Treasury rate for the last day of the year (opens the official FinCEN page in a new tab), and each year is filed on FinCEN Form 114.
The pension is the hard entry. A defined benefit scheme has no account balance, and practice on whether it belongs on the FBAR varies, as our post on whether a UK pension is reportable on the FBAR explains. Form 8938 is a separate test with its own threshold, for a single filer living abroad $200,000 at year end or $300,000 at any time.
What changes for a police officer with a green card
Less than most expect. A green card holder is a US tax resident until the status is given up in writing or ended by USCIS or a court, so the filing duty mirrors a citizen's. Article 19 is withheld from anyone admitted for permanent residence, and the same Streamlined test of 330 full days applies.
The IRS green card test (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) lists three ways the status ends: a written renunciation to USCIS, administrative termination by USCIS, or termination by a federal court. Letting the card expire is none of them. Our post on a green card that expired in the UK covers the evidence.
There is one extra trap. A green card holder living here may be able to claim UK residence under the treaty tie-breaker and file as a non-resident. For a long-term resident, the IRS expatriation tax page (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) says that being treated as resident in a foreign country under a treaty, without waiving its benefits, ends long-term resident status. That can bring the expatriation rules into play, so take advice before claiming it.
What might the catch-up look like for a detective in Bristol
Take a detective constable born in Ohio to British parents and brought to Bristol as a child. She joined the police eleven years ago, is in the 2015 scheme, works regular overtime, and has never filed a US return or FBAR. A Social Security number was issued when she was a baby.
Her adviser rebuilt three calendar years of gross pay from payslips, putting overtime worked each December into the January it was paid. With the UK tax credited, the salary produced no US tax. Interest on a cash ISA went into US income with no UK tax to set against it, leaving a small balance paid with interest. Her pension contributions were tested against Article 18(5), and the position taken was disclosed.
Her six FBARs list a current account, savings, the ISA and the account of a station football club where she has been treasurer, with the pension treated the same way each year. Her travel records show far more than 330 full days outside the US in every year, so the Foreign route was open. Our IRS streamlined filing service prepares packages like hers, and the full sequence is in our guide for people behind on US taxes in the UK.
General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.



