A US life insurance policy UK resident owners hold is a foreign policy for UK tax, so cash taken out, a surrender, a sale or the death of the life insured can produce a chargeable event gain taxed as income. The US measures the same events differently. It recovers premiums first on most withdrawals, and it excludes death proceeds paid to a beneficiary, so the UK can tax a gain that the US never sees. HMRC's helpsheet on gains on foreign life insurance policies (opens the official HMRC page in a new tab) sets out the UK rules.
This post is for US citizens and green card holders who bought whole life, universal life or similar cash-value cover while living in America and kept it after moving to Britain. It goes further than our guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation on one asset. It explains when HMRC treats a gain as arising, how the gain is measured, the relief for years spent outside the UK, what the US taxes, how the two fit together and a worked example. Term cover with no cash value rarely raises these questions.
Is a US life insurance policy taxable for a UK resident
Not year by year, in most cases, but on particular events. HMRC treats a policy issued by an insurer outside the UK as a foreign policy, and most foreign policies are non-qualifying. Gains on non-qualifying policies are charged to income tax when a chargeable event occurs, not as the cash value grows.
The helpsheet lists the common events: a full or part surrender, maturity, the death of the life insured, and a sale or assignment for value. A loan from the insurer can count as a part surrender. Gains are income, so capital losses and the capital gains annual exempt amount cannot be set against them, and gains on foreign policies normally carry no basic rate tax credit.
One exception produces an annual charge whether or not cash is taken. A personal portfolio bond is broadly a policy that lets the holder choose the assets that determine its value, beyond a permitted list of funds and deposits. Most US whole life and universal life policies will not be personal portfolio bonds, but variable contracts with self-selected investments should be checked with the insurer.
How does HMRC measure a gain on a foreign policy
On a full surrender, maturity or sale, the gain is total benefits less total premiums and earlier gains. On death, the same formula uses the surrender value immediately before death rather than the death benefit. On part surrenders, the gain is worked out at the end of each insurance year, after a cumulative allowance.
That allowance lets you take one twentieth of each premium for each year without an immediate gain, carried forward if unused, up to the total premiums paid. Withdrawals above it produce a gain at the end of the insurance year, which may not fall in the same tax year as the withdrawal. The helpsheet's own example shows a January withdrawal giving a June gain in the next tax year.
A US insurer may not issue a UK chargeable event certificate. The helpsheet says that where no certificate arrives but an event has happened, the gain should be worked out and reported anyway. The figures needed are the premiums, the benefits, any earlier part surrenders and, on death, the surrender value. Gains go in the Foreign section of the return, or on the SA106 foreign pages (opens the official HMRC page in a new tab) for paper filers.
- Full surrender or maturity. Total benefits less premiums and earlier gains
- Death of the life insured. Surrender value just before death less premiums and earlier gains
- Part surrender above the allowance. The excess, at the end of the insurance year
- Sale of the policy. Sale price, or market value between connected persons
Do years lived in the US reduce the UK gain
Yes, through a time apportioned reduction. Where you were not UK resident for part of the period in which you held the policy, the helpsheet reduces the gain by the fraction of foreign days in that period. For someone who bought the policy in America and moved later, that can remove a large share of the gain.
The calculation divides the number of foreign days by the number of days in the material interest period, which is the time during which you owned the rights or held them through a trust you created or as security. Foreign days are days in tax years when you were not UK resident, plus the overseas part of a split year. The reduction is not shown on any certificate, so you calculate it and deduct it yourself.
Top slicing relief can then soften the rate where the gain pushes other income into a higher band. The number of complete years used for it is cut by the whole years of non-residence. The helpsheet notes that different rules may apply to policies issued before 6 April 2013 and not varied or assigned since, so older US policies need a closer look at HMRC's manual.
What does the US tax on the same policy
Usually less, and at different moments. Publication 525 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) says life insurance proceeds paid because of the death of the insured are generally not taxable, unless the policy was transferred for a price. On a surrender for cash, only the amount above your cost is income, cost being broadly the premiums paid less refunds and dividends.
Partial withdrawals follow section 72. Publication 575 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) says distributions from a life insurance contract that is not a modified endowment contract, and not taken as an annuity, are taxed only to the extent they exceed the cost of the contract. A modified endowment contract is different: like a deferred annuity, its withdrawals are allocated to earnings first.
So the two systems often disagree on a withdrawal. The UK looks at the cumulative one-twentieth allowance; the US, for a standard policy, looks at whether withdrawals have passed total premiums. A large early withdrawal can create a UK gain with no US income, and a later surrender can produce US income in a year when the UK gain is reduced for foreign days.
How do the two countries relieve the same gain
Only where both tax the same income, and the order depends on the treaty and on sourcing. The US-UK treaty (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) has no article written for life policy gains, and for a US citizen the saving clause keeps US tax in place whichever article applies. Article 24(6) then limits the UK credit to the US tax the treaty would allow on a non-citizen.
Where the UK taxes a gain the US does not, as on death or on a withdrawal within the policy's cost, there is no US tax to credit and no UK tax to set against US tax. The UK charge simply stands. Where both tax a surrender, the US credit for UK tax on Form 1116 depends on how the income is sourced and categorised, which should be settled before either return is filed.
Timing can split the two charges across years. A UK gain on a part surrender arises at the end of the insurance year, while the US counts income when it is received, so the UK tax may relate to a different US year. Our post on paid or accrued UK tax explains how the crediting method affects that.
- Death benefit. UK gain on the deceased; generally no US income tax
- Withdrawal under the allowance. No immediate UK gain; US income only above cost on a standard policy
- Withdrawal over the allowance. UK gain at year end; US income only above cost on a standard policy
- Full surrender. Gain in both countries, measured and reduced differently
How the rules work for one policyholder by role
Take a US citizen who bought a universal life policy from a US insurer while working in Chicago, then moved to Bristol as an engineer twelve years later. She has been UK resident since, and is considering a large withdrawal to fund a house deposit.
On the UK side, a withdrawal above her cumulative allowance gives a gain at the end of the insurance year, which she reports on her return through our UK Self Assessment service. Her time apportioned reduction reflects the years she held the policy before arriving. On the US side, if her policy is not a modified endowment contract and the withdrawal stays within her premiums, there is no income on her Form 1040.
If she instead holds the policy until death, the UK charges a gain on the surrender value immediately before death as her income for that year, after the same reduction, while her beneficiaries generally receive the death benefit free of US income tax. Estate planning is a separate question, covered by our estate and trust planning work, and our individual tax returns team prepares both returns. For UK-issued contracts, see our post on UK investment bonds and life policies on the FBAR, and for the wider picture the guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation.
General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.



