Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

Double tax reliefBy US UK Tax Returns16 Nov 20266 min read

US annuity UK resident rules: who taxes the payments

Retired couple read an insurance statement over tea in a stone cottage, a US annuity UK resident case

Payments from a US commercial annuity can be taxed in both countries, and each treats the return of the purchase price in its own way.

Under the US annuity UK resident rules in the treaty, a commercial annuity bought from a US insurer and paid to someone living in Britain is taxable only in the UK. Article 17(4) gives annuities to the country of residence. A US citizen is the exception: the saving clause lets the United States tax the payments too, and Article 24(6) then decides which country gives way. The treaty text is among the US-UK treaty documents (opens the official IRS page in a new tab).

This post is for British returners who bought an annuity while working in America, and for US citizens retired in the UK who hold one. It goes further than our guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation on a single kind of payment. It covers what counts as an annuity under the treaty, the citizen's position, how each country taxes the payments, how a non-citizen stops US withholding, and a worked example. Annuities paid out of a 401(k), an IRA or a 403(b) plan are pensions under a different paragraph and are not covered here.

What counts as a US annuity under the treaty

A stated sum paid at stated times for life, or for a set or ascertainable period, under an obligation to pay in return for adequate and full consideration other than services. A contract bought from an insurer with your own money usually fits. Payments from a pension scheme do not, even if they are labelled annuity payments.

The Treasury technical explanation (opens the official US Treasury page in a new tab) draws both boundaries. Distributions from a pension scheme fall under Article 17(1), so an annuity paid from a 401(k) or a 403(b) plan is taxed as a pension. An annuity received for services is treated as deferred compensation and goes to the articles on business profits or employment. Article 17(4) is left with what the industry calls a non-qualified or commercial annuity.

The label on the contract matters less than its terms. The questions to answer before choosing an article are these:

  • Was it bought with after-tax money from an insurer, or funded by an employer plan
  • Do payments run for a life, a fixed term or both
  • Have payments started, or is the contract still deferred
  • Does any part of the value come from salary deferred under an employment arrangement

Which country taxes a US annuity paid to a UK resident

The UK, for anyone who is not a US citizen or green card holder. Article 17(4) says an annuity beneficially owned by a resident of one country is taxable only there. A British national who has come home, or any other UK resident without US status, pays UK tax on the payments and none in the United States.

For a US citizen, the technical explanation says paragraph 4 is subject to the saving clause, so the US taxes the annuity as though the treaty did not exist. The UK taxes it as well, because the recipient lives here. Article 24(6) of the treaty sets the order of relief for a citizen resident in the UK.

Under that paragraph, the UK credits only the US tax that the treaty would allow on a UK resident who is not a US citizen. Under Article 17(4) that is none, so the UK taxes the payments in full without a credit. The US then allows a credit for the UK tax, treating the income as arising in the UK so far as needed to avoid double tax. Our post on the saving clause explains the wider pattern.

How does the US tax the annuity payments

Under the General Rule, which splits each payment into a tax-free return of cost and a taxable part. Publication 575 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) says annuities paid under a nonqualified plan must use it, and that the shorter Simplified Method is not available for them. Publication 939, which sets out the rule, names a purchased commercial annuity as one such plan.

The tax-free part depends on the ratio of your investment in the contract to the total expected return. Your cost is generally the net investment at the annuity starting date. The exclusion stops once the whole cost has been recovered, after which each payment is fully taxable. If the annuitant dies before recovering the cost, the unrecovered amount is allowed as an itemised deduction on the final return.

Withdrawals from a deferred contract before payments start are treated differently. Publication 575 allocates them to earnings first, so they are taxable until the gain is used up, and an additional tax can apply before age 59½. The taxable part of a nonqualified annuity also counts for the net investment income tax (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) at 3.8%, which is generally not creditable under domestic law, and treaty-based claims are contested.

How does the UK tax an annuity from a US insurer

As income, with part of each payment possibly exempt. A purchased life annuity, defined in section 423 of the Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005, is one bought for money from a business that grants annuities on human life, running for a period ending with a death. Section 717 exempts a capital element from each payment, worked out under section 719.

HMRC's Insurance Policyholder Taxation Manual computes the exempt proportion by applying the purchase price over the actuarial value of the payments, using prescribed mortality tables. For an annuity from a non-UK insurer, the manual says an exempt capital amount may still be available, but only if the insurer meets requirements beyond the usual procedure, including a UK tax representative to handle the PLA6 forms. It is worth asking a US insurer early whether it has made that arrangement.

The payments go on the SA106 foreign pages (opens the official HMRC page in a new tab), not the main return. Section 718 excludes some annuities from the exemption, such as those bought because a will directed it. An annuity certain, paid for a fixed term without a life contingency, sits outside the scheme, but the manual says the capital part of each payment is still exempt and the interest part is taxed as interest.

  • Life annuity from a US insurer. Taxable on SA106; capital element exempt only if HMRC's overseas-payer conditions are met
  • Annuity certain for a fixed term. Return of capital not taxed; interest element taxed as interest
  • Deferred contract not yet paying. UK chargeable event rules can apply on withdrawals or surrender
  • Annuity paid from a US retirement plan. A pension under Article 17(1), not covered by these rules

How does a non-citizen stop US withholding on an annuity

By giving the insurer a treaty claim. For chapter 3 withholding, Publication 515 says that without a treaty exemption a payer must withhold at the statutory rate of 30% on a US-source distribution. It adds that most treaties exempt non-government pensions and annuities, though not always lump sums or deferred compensation.

A British returner claims Article 17(4) on Form W-8BEN (opens the official IRS page in a new tab), giving a UK address and a UK tax reference. A form generally stays valid until the end of the third calendar year after signing, unless circumstances change, and a move back to the United States counts. Our Form W-8BEN page covers how to complete it.

Where tax was withheld before the form reached the insurer, it is usually recovered by filing a US nonresident return for the year. Publication 519 says Form 8833 is not needed for a treaty claim that reduces or modifies the taxation of annuities, so the claim on the return is simpler than many treaty positions. Our individual tax returns service handles the reclaim.

How does a US annuity UK resident case work in practice

Take a US citizen who retired from a career in Boston to Norfolk and lives on a life annuity bought from a Massachusetts insurer, plus UK savings. She holds no British citizenship and files both returns each year. Her file holds the contract, the confirmation of the price she paid, each year's Form 1099-R and the insurer's annual statements. The price paid matters twice: it drives the US exclusion ratio, and it is the starting point for any UK capital element. The payments arrive in dollars, so her UK return needs sterling figures, converted on the same basis every year.

On her Form 1040, the insurer's Form 1099-R gives the gross payments, and the General Rule exclusion ratio removes the return of her cost until it is fully recovered. On the UK side, the whole of each payment goes on SA106 unless the insurer can supply the information HMRC requires for an overseas payer's capital element. Her first question to the insurer is whether it has a UK tax representative.

The UK tax on the annuity, due by 31 January, is credited against her US tax on Form 1116 in the passive category, which the instructions say includes annuities. Because the UK figure may cover more of each payment than the US figure, the UK tax can exceed the US tax on it, and the excess is a carryover. Our treaty relief and US-UK pensions work prepares both returns together. The guide to avoiding US-UK double taxation shows how this sits beside the other treaty articles.

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

Avoiding US-UK Double Taxation: The Treaty, Foreign Tax Credits and the FEIE

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

I moved back to England and still get monthly payments from a US annuity. Do I pay US tax on them?

Not if you are not a US citizen or green card holder. Article 17(4) of the treaty makes an annuity taxable only in the country where the annuitant lives, so the payments are taxed in the UK. Give the insurer a Form W-8BEN claiming the treaty exemption, or US tax may be withheld at the statutory rate and need a nonresident return to recover.

Is an annuity from my old 401(k) treated the same as one I bought myself?

No. The Treasury technical explanation says the treaty's annuity paragraph does not cover distributions from a pension scheme, so an annuity paid out of a 401(k), an IRA or a 403(b) plan is a pension under Article 17(1). Different rules apply, including the protection for amounts that would be exempt in the US. A commercial annuity bought from an insurer is the one Article 17(4) covers.

Does HMRC let me deduct what I paid for the annuity?

Possibly, through the capital element. UK law exempts part of each payment from a purchased life annuity, based on the purchase price and mortality tables. For an overseas insurer, HMRC's manual says the exemption needs extra conditions to be met, including the insurer appointing a UK tax representative. If those are not in place, ask HMRC how it will treat your payments.

As a US citizen, will I get a UK credit for the US tax on my annuity?

Generally not. Article 24(6) limits the UK credit to the US tax the treaty would allow on a UK resident who is not a US citizen, and Article 17(4) allows none. The UK therefore taxes the payments in full, and the United States gives the credit instead, on Form 1116 against the US tax on the same payments.

Do I need to report my US annuity on the FBAR?

The FBAR covers financial accounts held outside the United States, so a contract with a US insurer is not normally the kind of account it asks about. A cash-value annuity with a UK insurer is a different matter. Annuities with cash value can also be specified foreign financial assets for Form 8938 when issued by a foreign insurer, so check where the issuer is based.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us