Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

ReportingBy US UK Tax Returns14 Nov 20268 min read

UK lifetime annuities on the FBAR and Form 8938

Retired man in a cardigan reads an insurer letter by a seaside window, checking a UK annuity for the FBAR

An annuity statement rarely mentions a cash value, yet that single figure decides whether the policy belongs on the FBAR, and Form 8938 asks a wider question.

On the UK annuity FBAR question, everything turns on cash value. FinCEN's FBAR instructions (opens the official FinCEN page in a new tab) count an annuity policy as a financial account only when it has a cash value, so a lifetime annuity in payment that gives nothing back on cancellation usually stays off the FBAR, while a deferred annuity you can still cash in goes on it. Form 8938 is wider. Its definition takes in annuity contracts held with a foreign insurer, and an annuity bought with pension money can also be read as an interest in a foreign pension plan.

This post is for US citizens and green card holders in Britain who have turned some or all of a pension pot into an annuity, or who bought one with savings or an inheritance. It adds one product to our guide to FBAR and FATCA for UK residents. Pension pots in general are covered in our post on whether a UK pension is reportable on the FBAR, and bonds and endowments in our post on UK investment bonds and life policies. Here we deal with the annuity itself, the two ways of buying one, valuation, and a decision checklist.

Is a UK annuity reportable on the FBAR

Only if it has a cash value. The FBAR regulation at 31 CFR 1010.350 lists an insurance or annuity policy with a cash value as a financial account. An annuity that pays an income for life and offers no amount on surrender has no cash value, so on that wording it is not an account for the FBAR.

The IRS manual on the FBAR (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) treats the cash value of a policy as its account value, which is why the test is cash value and not income. A lifetime annuity bought from a UK insurer typically exchanges a lump sum for a promise of payments, and the buyer cannot take the lump sum back. Read the contract to confirm that before treating it as outside the report. The bank account the payments arrive in is an ordinary foreign account and stays in the aggregate.

The FBAR's retirement exception does not help either way. It applies to participants in plans described in Internal Revenue Code sections 401(a), 403(a) and 403(b), which are US plans. A UK registered pension scheme is not one of them, so an annuity with a cash value is reported whether or not it came out of a pension.

  • Lifetime annuity in payment with no surrender value: generally not an FBAR account
  • Deferred annuity not yet paying, with a surrender value: an FBAR account
  • Fixed-term annuity: depends on whether the contract pays anything on surrender or withdrawal
  • Annuity with a guaranteed period: check whether any amount can be cashed in while you are alive
  • Bank account receiving the payments: always counted, as with any UK account

How do you tell whether an annuity has a cash value

Look for any amount the insurer would pay you if you surrendered, cancelled or withdrew from the contract, or any amount you could borrow against it. If such an amount exists, the contract has a cash value. If the contract only pays income as it falls due, it does not.

The FBAR rules do not define cash value. The US FATCA regulations, at 26 CFR 1.1471-5, do: broadly, any amount payable on surrender, termination, cancellation or withdrawal, or that any person can borrow under or against the contract. That definition was written for financial institutions, but it is the clearest official test available, and we use it as a working check for the FBAR too.

Where a value exists, the FBAR figure is its highest point in the calendar year, converted at the Treasury rate for the last day of the year. FinCEN's page on reporting maximum account value (opens the official FinCEN page in a new tab) accepts a reasonable approximation and periodic statements that fairly reflect the peak. Our post on the FBAR maximum value and exchange rate works through the arithmetic, and the entry itself goes on FinCEN Form 114 with the insurer as the institution.

Is a lifetime annuity a specified foreign financial asset

Usually, yes, though by more than one route. Form 8938 borrows the FATCA definition of a financial account, which includes an annuity contract issued by an insurer, and an annuity bought with pension money can also be an interest in a foreign pension plan. Either way, the absence of a cash value does not by itself keep it off the form.

The Instructions for Form 8938 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) describe a financial account as including any cash value life insurance or annuity contract maintained by a foreign insurer. The regulation they rest on, 26 CFR 1.6038D-1, points to 26 CFR 1.1471-5, which lists a cash value insurance contract or an annuity contract. That regulation also excludes a non-investment linked, non-transferable, immediate life annuity that monetises a qualifying retirement account.

The Form 8938 regulation switches off the FATCA exclusions for retirement accounts and for accounts excluded under an intergovernmental agreement, but it does not name the immediate annuity exclusion. We have found no IRS guidance on how that applies to a UK lifetime annuity. Even if the exclusion applied, the foreign pension plan route would arguably remain, so we report the annuity where the form is due. Our post on what counts as a specified foreign financial asset covers the categories.

Does it matter whether pension money bought the annuity

Yes, for Form 8938 and for income tax, though not for the FBAR. A lifetime annuity bought from a pension pot stays inside the pension rules. A purchased life annuity bought with your own savings is an ordinary insurance contract. The FBAR applies the same cash value test to both.

HMRC's Pensions Tax Manual describes a lifetime annuity as one bought from an insurer using funds from a money purchase arrangement, with the payments treated as coming from the registered pension scheme that bought it and taxed as pension income. That supports reporting it on Form 8938 as an interest in a foreign pension plan. HMRC's guidance on registered pension schemes (opens the official HMRC page in a new tab) under the exchange of information rules also says products under registered pension schemes are excluded from UK FATCA reporting while benefits are paid out as well as while savings build up.

A purchased life annuity is different. HMRC's insurance manual describes it as an annuity bought from an insurer that is not a pension annuity, with part of each payment treated as a return of capital for UK tax. There is no pension plan to anchor it, and the immediate annuity exclusion needs a retirement account behind it, so we report it on Form 8938 as an annuity contract with a foreign insurer.

  • Bought from a pension pot: an interest in a foreign pension plan, and possibly an annuity contract as well
  • Bought with free cash: an annuity contract maintained by a foreign insurer
  • FBAR for either: listed only if the contract has a cash value
  • UK FATCA reporting by the insurer: generally excluded for pension annuities, which does not change your Form 8938

What value goes on Form 8938 for a UK annuity

For an annuity bought within a pension, use the fair market value of your interest at the year end if you can find it. If you cannot, the instructions let you use the value of payments received in the year, and zero if there were none. For a purchased life annuity, a reasonable estimate of its maximum value is required.

The pension rule comes from 26 CFR 1.6038D-5 and is repeated in the instructions. It was written for interests whose value cannot be known from readily accessible information, which describes most lifetime annuities, since insurers rarely state a value for a contract in payment. For a purchased life annuity, the same regulation asks for a reasonable estimate of maximum fair market value. The FATCA rules let an insurer value an immediate annuity by discounting expected payments, but that method is set for institutions, not individuals, so we agree the approach with the client and record it.

The threshold for someone living abroad and not filing jointly is $200,000 at year end or $300,000 at any time, and for joint filers abroad $400,000 at year end or $600,000 at any time. If the scheme behind a pension annuity is reported on a timely Form 3520, the duplicative reporting exception in the instructions may let you identify it in Part IV instead of listing it again. Our Form 8938 page covers the rest of the form.

How a retired US citizen in Norwich reports two annuities

Take a US citizen, a retired university librarian in Norwich, who used part of her SIPP to buy a lifetime annuity and left the rest in drawdown. Years earlier she used an inheritance to buy a purchased life annuity from a different UK insurer. Neither contract offers a surrender value, and both pay into her UK current account.

Her FBAR lists the current account, her savings and the SIPP drawdown pot at their highest values. Neither annuity appears, because neither has a cash value. Her Form 8938 is due because the drawdown pot and accounts pass the abroad threshold. She lists the lifetime annuity as an interest in a foreign pension plan, valued by the distribution rule since the insurer gives no figure, and the purchased life annuity as an annuity contract, at a documented estimate.

Both streams of payments are income on her US return. Publication 575 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) explains how pension and annuity payments are taxed and how any cost in the contract is recovered, and the treaty may change the answer for the pension annuity. Our US and UK pensions service handles that side, alongside her US individual tax return.

Which annuity checklist settles both reports

Work through the contract first, then the source of the money, then the threshold for each form. The FBAR is due 15 April, extended automatically to 15 October and goes to FinCEN, while Form 8938 travels with your tax return. The IRS comparison of Form 8938 and FBAR requirements (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) is a useful cross-check on the differences.

Where an annuity was left off earlier reports, the fix depends on what else was missed. Our foreign income and FBAR reporting service covers current and past years, the document checklist lists the papers we ask for, and the full account rules sit in our guide to FBAR and FATCA for UK residents.

  • Find the contract schedule and note any amount payable on surrender, cancellation or withdrawal
  • If there is such an amount, list the annuity on the FBAR at its highest value; if not, leave it off and keep a note
  • Confirm whether pension funds or your own money paid the premium
  • Test Form 8938 against the threshold for your residence and filing status
  • If due, report a pension annuity as a pension interest and a purchased annuity as a contract with a foreign insurer
  • Record the valuation method and use it again each year

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

FBAR and FATCA for UK Residents: Reporting UK Accounts to the US

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

I bought an annuity with my pension tax-free lump sum. Is that a pension annuity?

Generally not. Once the tax-free lump sum is paid to you, it is your own money, and an annuity bought with it is generally a purchased life annuity rather than a lifetime annuity from the scheme. That changes its Form 8938 treatment and its UK tax, though not the FBAR cash value test. The paperwork from the insurer will normally say which kind it is.

My annuity pays out for a guaranteed ten years even if I die. Does that give it a cash value?

Not necessarily. A guarantee that continues payments to your estate or a beneficiary after death is different from an amount you could take in cash while alive. Look for a surrender, commutation or withdrawal right in the contract. If none exists, we would not treat the guarantee as a cash value for the FBAR, but the contract terms decide it.

My UK insurer says it does not report my annuity to HMRC under FATCA. Can I leave it off Form 8938?

No. The insurer's exclusion comes from the UK and US intergovernmental agreement and binds only the institution. The Form 8938 instructions say pension and similar accounts excluded under an agreement must still be reported by the individual. If your assets pass the threshold and a return is due, the annuity belongs in the total whatever the insurer sends to HMRC.

What if I bought the annuity before I became a US resident?

The date of purchase does not matter. What counts is whether you are a US person for the year being reported and whether you hold the contract during that year. A green card holder who moved to Britain with an annuity bought years earlier tests it in exactly the same way as one bought last month.

Should I tell my financial adviser to avoid annuities because I am American?

Reporting is not by itself a reason to avoid an annuity. The forms are information returns and carry no tax of their own. The more important questions are how the payments are taxed in each country and whether the US treats the product sensibly, which depends on the contract. It is worth having those reviewed before you buy rather than afterwards.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us