Skip to content
US UK Tax Returns

ReportingBy US UK Tax Returns9 Nov 20267 min read

Sharia-compliant UK bank accounts on the FBAR and the US return

Couple in a Birmingham kitchen review bank statements over tea and dates, checking an Islamic bank account for the FBAR

A profit-sharing account is still a bank account to FinCEN, so a Sharia-compliant label changes how the return is described, not whether the account is reported.

An account with a UK Islamic bank goes on the FBAR in the same way as any other UK bank account. FinCEN defines a financial account by what it does, listing savings, demand, deposit, time deposit and other accounts kept with a financial institution, and says nothing about whether the account pays interest. Form 8938 takes the same approach to depository accounts at foreign financial institutions.

This post is for US citizens and green card holders in Britain who bank in line with their faith: Islamic current accounts, profit-sharing savings run on a mudarabah or wakala basis, fixed-term deposits, and home purchase plans. It goes deeper than our guide to FBAR and FATCA for UK residents on one question, how each product lands on the FBAR, on Form 8938 and on the two tax returns, and it ends with a decision list and a worked example.

Does an Islamic bank account go on the FBAR

Yes. An Islamic current account, a profit-sharing savings account and a fixed-term deposit held with a bank in the UK are all foreign financial accounts for the FBAR. They count towards the aggregate threshold, and once your combined highest balances pass it, each one is listed on the report like any other UK account.

The FinCEN filing instructions (opens the official FinCEN page in a new tab) say a financial account includes, but is not limited to, a securities, brokerage, savings, demand, checking, deposit, time deposit or other account maintained with a financial institution. The list describes what an account does, not the contract that sits behind it. A current account structured as a qard, a savings account run as a mudarabah and a term deposit run as a wakala each hold a customer's money with a deposit-taking institution, so each fits the definition on its plain wording.

The IRS FBAR guidance page (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) adds that whether an account produced taxable income has no effect on whether it is a foreign financial account. A current account that pays nothing at all is therefore reportable on the same footing as one that pays a return. The threshold is $10,000 across all your foreign accounts combined, and the report goes to FinCEN separately from the tax return, due 15 April, extended automatically to 15 October. Our FBAR page covers the filing mechanics.

Which account type box applies on the FBAR

For an ordinary Islamic current, savings or fixed-term deposit account with a UK bank, our practice is to tick Bank. The form offers three boxes, Bank, Securities and Other, and asks for the one that best describes the account. The box describes the account; it plays no part in deciding whether the account is reportable.

The IRS manual on the FBAR (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) groups savings deposits, demand deposits, checking accounts and time deposits together as bank accounts, and separately treats an account with a person in the business of accepting deposits as a financial agency as an other financial account. A profit-sharing account at a UK bank authorised to take deposits is, in our reading, a bank account in that sense. Sukuk or Sharia-screened funds bought through an investment platform sit in a securities account instead, and it is the platform account that goes on the report.

Maximum value follows the usual rule. FinCEN's maximum account value guidance (opens the official FinCEN page in a new tab) lets you rely on periodic statements, and the figure that counts is the balance those statements show, not the expected profit rate quoted when the account was opened. Profit forms part of the balance once the bank credits it. Each highest balance is then converted to dollars at the Treasury year-end rate.

Do Sharia-compliant accounts count for Form 8938

Yes, where the Form 8938 thresholds are met. The instructions define a financial account as any depository or custodial account maintained by a foreign financial institution, and a UK Islamic bank that takes deposits in the ordinary course of its business is one. The Sharia structure does not move an account outside either definition.

The Instructions for Form 8938 (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) describe a foreign financial institution, in most cases, as one that is not a US entity and meets one of several tests, the first being that it accepts deposits in the ordinary course of a banking or similar business. The IRS comparison of Form 8938 and FBAR requirements (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) marks deposit and custodial accounts at foreign financial institutions as reportable on both forms, with no exception for any style of banking.

The thresholds are much higher for people living abroad. A single filer in the UK files once specified foreign financial assets exceed $200,000 at year end or $300,000 at any time, and joint filers once they exceed $400,000 at year end or $600,000 at any time. Below those figures the accounts appear on the FBAR only. Our Form 8938 page explains the rest of the form, including the part where income from reported accounts is summarised against the schedule on which it was reported.

Is a home purchase plan reported on the FBAR or Form 8938

Generally not, in our reading. A home purchase plan is a way of financing a home: the customer owes the bank acquisition payments and rent, and holds no deposit with it. The FBAR and Form 8938 definitions describe accounts and assets that hold value for the customer, and neither text lists a financing arrangement among them.

Plans offered in the UK are usually built as diminishing shared ownership, often called diminishing musharakah, or on a lease basis. HMRC's manuals list diminishing shared ownership among the alternative finance arrangements recognised in UK income tax law. None of the FinCEN or IRS texts we have checked mentions Islamic home finance by name, so our conclusion rests on the general definitions. We present it as our reading, not a published rule.

Two things around the plan do matter. The current account from which the monthly payments leave is a bank account and goes on the FBAR. The home itself is real estate: the IRS manual says real estate is not a financial account, and the IRS comparison table lists foreign real estate held directly as reportable on neither form. Where a plan places title in a company, trust or nominee, we read the documents before anything is left off.

Repaying a sterling financing can also raise US currency questions. Our post on sterling mortgages and currency gains explains those rules for a conventional mortgage. Whether they reach a home purchase plan depends on how the plan is characterised for US purposes, a point we review case by case.

How is the profit on a mudarabah or wakala account taxed

In the UK, it is taxed as interest. HMRC's Savings and Investment Manual says that for non-corporate investors, alternative finance return is treated as if it were interest for UK income tax purposes. On the US side we have found no Islamic-finance rule for individual depositors, so the return is reported by its economic substance.

HMRC's manual names the arrangements. In a mudarabah the bank invests the depositor's money in Sharia-compliant ways and credits a share of the proceeds. In a wakala the bank acts as the depositor's agent and keeps any return above the expected profit as an incentive fee. Both fall within the UK alternative finance rules, so the profit goes on the Self Assessment return in the same place as bank interest when a return is needed.

We have not found published IRS guidance on how a US individual reports the return on a UK profit-sharing deposit. Our reading is that it is a cash return on money placed with a bank, and we generally report it as interest-type income on Form 1040 in the year it is credited. UK tax paid on it can usually be claimed under the foreign tax credit (opens the official IRS page in a new tab) rules. A different structure, or one where the depositor genuinely bears losses, may call for a different answer.

Decision list: Islamic products on the FBAR and Form 8938

The list below gives our working position for the products most UK Islamic banks offer. It assumes the FBAR threshold is passed and, for Form 8938, that the filer's foreign financial assets exceed the relevant threshold. Where an answer rests on our reading rather than a stated rule, the list says so.

Two points sit beside the list. A non-US pooled fund is commonly a PFIC however it screens its investments, which brings separate US reporting. And a cash ISA run on a profit-sharing basis is still an ISA, with no US tax protection, as our post on ISAs on the FBAR and Form 8938 explains.

  • Islamic current account (qard). FBAR: yes, as a bank account. Form 8938: yes, a depository account
  • Mudarabah or wakala savings account. FBAR: yes, Bank box in our practice. Form 8938: yes
  • Fixed-term deposit. FBAR: yes, as a time deposit. Form 8938: yes, a depository account
  • Sukuk or Sharia-screened funds on a platform. FBAR: yes, the platform account. Form 8938: yes, the account
  • Home purchase plan. FBAR: generally no, in our reading. Form 8938: generally no, in our reading
  • Home held under the plan. FBAR: no, it is real estate. Form 8938: no, if held directly

Worked example: one household's Islamic accounts

Take a US citizen working as a pharmacist in Birmingham, married to a British spouse and filing as married filing separately. In her sole name she holds an Islamic current account, a wakala savings account and a one-year fixed-term deposit opened partway through the year, all with one UK bank. The family home is financed through a home purchase plan with the same bank.

For the FBAR she lists the current account, the savings account and the term deposit, each under the Bank box. Their combined highest balances pass the threshold, so all three go on the report, each valued from its own statements and converted at the year-end rate. The term deposit counts although it was opened partway through the year, because the test looks at any time in the calendar year. The home purchase plan is left off.

Form 8938 is not needed, because her accounts together stay below $200,000 at year end or $300,000 at any time for a filer living abroad who does not file jointly. Her US return reports the wakala profit and the term deposit return as interest-type income, alongside the UK tax paid on them. Where she needs a UK Self Assessment return, the same amounts are interest there. We prepare both through our individual tax return and foreign income and FBAR reporting work, and the guide to FBAR and FATCA for UK residents covers the rest of the reporting picture.

General information, not advice. The right answer depends on your circumstances and the tax year concerned.

Part of our guide

FBAR and FATCA for UK Residents: Reporting UK Accounts to the US

Read the full guide

Questions we are asked

My bank pays profit instead of interest. Do I still have to report the account?

Yes. The FBAR definition of a financial account covers savings, deposit and time deposit accounts kept with a financial institution, and the IRS says whether an account produces taxable income has no bearing on whether it is reportable. The label on the return does not change that. The account counts towards the aggregate threshold and, where the higher thresholds are passed, goes on Form 8938 as well.

Should I report the expected profit rate or the actual balance?

The actual balance. The FBAR asks for the maximum value of each account during the year, and FinCEN lets you rely on periodic statements to find it. An expected or indicative profit rate is a projection, not a value. Profit becomes part of the balance once the bank credits it, and the highest balance is converted to dollars at the Treasury year-end rate.

Does the amount I still owe on my Islamic home finance go on Form 8938?

In our reading, no. Form 8938 reports specified foreign financial assets that you hold. The amount you owe the bank under a home purchase plan is a liability, not an asset, and the home is real estate, which the IRS lists as not reportable when held directly. A plan that puts title in a company, trust or nominee needs a closer look at the documents.

I hold sukuk directly rather than through a platform. Is that on the FBAR?

Generally not on the FBAR, because the IRS manual says stocks, bonds and similar instruments held directly are not financial accounts. Form 8938 is different: the IRS comparison table lists foreign securities not held in a financial account as reportable once the thresholds are passed. Sukuk held through a platform or bank custody account are covered by reporting that account instead.

My Islamic savings sit inside a cash ISA. Does that change anything?

Not for US purposes. The US does not recognise the ISA wrapper, so the account goes on the FBAR and, where the thresholds are met, on Form 8938, and the profit is reported on the US return. On the UK side the ISA protection still applies. The two systems simply treat the same account differently, and the US return has to follow the US rules.

Ready to talk it through?

Tell us where you live, what you hold and which years are outstanding. We will say what applies and what it involves before any work begins.

Contact us